- Median 4.2 seconds per 30-second track
- Tempo right on 10 of 11 prompts
- Editable plan, re-roll one section
$6/mo
Try Eleven MusicThe most comprehensive AI music generator test ever conducted
Out of 36, I tested and ranked the 10 best AI music generators to see which ones really live up to their claims. The whole list is on the AI music generators page. Part of the AI tools directory on RankDude.


Tested and written by Miles Foster
Based on hands-on reviews, each graded on the same 10 tests, ranked by grade.
I signed up to every AI music generator on this page myself, gave each the same briefs, published the sites for real and ran the same 10 tests on what was live. Every grade, screenshot and measurement is on its review, and each test site stays monitored for 30 days after the test. Here are the 10 best, highest first.
The 10 AI music generators in grade order: three findings from each review, the grade out of 5 and the lowest plan price its pricing page lists. The 10 test grades are on each review.
$6/mo
Try Eleven Music$10.49/mo
Try OpenMusic AI$9.99/mo
Try Somio AI$8/mo
Try Loudly$4.50/mo
Try MiniMax Music$11/mo
Try AIVA$11.90/mo
Try AirMusic$8.33/mo
Try MusicAI$7.20/mo
Try BeMusic$14.90/mo
Try MakeBestMusicI wrote 12 fixed prompts before opening any generator, pasted each one in once and kept the first track, then measured the files I could get and timed every generation. Here is what I found.
Use an AI music generator when you want a quick song or background track from a written prompt: an idea to try, a tune for a video or a short jingle. Free plans differ a lot in what you can keep, because several give you no file at all, and most free music is for personal use only, so read the licence before you publish or sell anything. If you need a voice reading text aloud, use an AI text to speech tool instead.
I tested, reviewed and ranked every AI music generator below. Each block has my verdict, its best and worst test results, the video review and the full story.
My pick for fast songs you can edit. It made each 30-second track in a median of 4.2 seconds, matched the tempo on 10 of 11 prompts and let me re-roll a single section. But the free plan gives no download, and free music is personal use only.
Video review · 5:13
Eleven Music made a 30-second track in a median of 4.2 seconds and fully met 9 of 12 prompts. The tempo came within 10 BPM on 10 of 11 prompts, and the Spanish reggaeton had 94 percent of its words sung as written. Every song comes with a written plan you can edit.
The weak spots are the free plan and the endings. Four of 12 tracks stop dead at the 30-second mark, the folk ballad came back with no words I could hear, and stems and downloads need a paid plan. I could not download a file, so I measured the stream.
It suits anyone who wants quick songs with lyrics to try out and will pay before using them in business. I tested on the free plan, signed in with Google, with 10,000 credits a month, where a 30-second track costs 450 of them.
My pick for a full song with its own lyrics. It wrote the lyrics and returned two songs of 3:02 and 3:22, the first playable after 43 seconds. But the free plan starts with 2.5 credits, a generation costs 2, and a download costs 2 more.
Video review · 4:35
OpenMusic AI returned two songs from one press, of 3:02 and 3:22, with lyrics it wrote itself. The first was playable after 43 seconds and both after 67. The stream measured 184 kbps MP3 at -14.7 LUFS with no clipped samples, and the Remix menu offers Extend and Replace Section.
I ran only one generation, so prompt adherence, vocals, structure and controls are not graded. The free plan starts with 2.5 credits, a generation costs 2 and a download costs 2, so I did not download a file. The pricing page crosses out commercial use on Free.
It suits someone who wants to hear a full song with lyrics before paying, and who will read the licence before any business use. I tested on the free plan, signed in with Google, with no card. Only five of the ten tests could be graded.
My pick for a clean MP3 from one prompt. Somio AI returned two songs in about 59 seconds, and the free 320 kbps MP3 measured clean with almost no clipping. But 10 free credits pay for one generation, and free songs are personal use only.
Video review · 4:42
Somio AI turned my pop prompt into two songs of 2:44 and 2:56 in about 59 seconds. I downloaded one as a 320 kbps MP3 and measured it: loudness -14.3 LUFS, a true peak of -1.3 dBFS and 0.001 percent of samples clipped. The MP3 download is free.
Everything else stopped there. The 10 free credits paid for one generation, so one of my 12 prompts ran and six tests are graded. WAV and the commercial licence carry a paid mark, the edit tools cost credits, and free songs shared in public need a visible credit to Somio AI.
It suits someone who wants to try one idea and then pay for commercial use; free songs become eligible for commercial use once you buy an eligible paid plan. I tested on the free plan, signed in with Google, on the Somio 3.5 model, with no card.
My pick for a quick instrumental to try. Loudly's VEGA models made two tracks in 10.5 and 12.6 seconds, and the MANTA 1 model returned songs of up to 3:33 in about a minute. But the free VEGA tracks are short previews, and free use is non-commercial.
Video review · 5:15
Loudly's VEGA models made two instrumentals in 10.5 and 12.6 seconds, and the MANTA 1 model, which sings, took 54.5 and 60.1 seconds for tracks of 1:10 to 3:33. The one MP3 I downloaded was 192 kbps at -15.5 LUFS with 0.001 percent of samples clipped.
The free plan cuts the VEGA tracks to previews of 23 to 27 seconds, allows one MP3 a day and locks WAV and stems. Loudly keeps the rights to its output. The 50 credits paid for four generations, so three of my 12 prompts ran and six tests are graded.
It suits someone who wants quick background tracks to try an idea and will pay before using the music in business. I tested on the free plan, signed in with Google on 6 November, with no card.
My pick for many full tracks for free. MiniMax Music made all 12 of my prompts on the free plan, and every 256 kbps MP3 download was free. But each track took a median of about four minutes, and free music is personal use only.
Video review · 4:14
MiniMax Music made a track for all 12 prompts, from 0:49 to 4:08 long, for 3,600 of the 10,000 free credits. Every one downloaded as a free 256 kbps MP3 with no credits taken, and one press of the Quantity box made three tracks at once.
Waiting is the cost. Tracks arrived in 105 to 403 seconds, and the 30-second corporate loop came out at 2:47. Eight of 12 true peaks went above full scale, and the lo-fi beat had 2.8 percent of its samples clipped. There is no stem, WAV, editing, or length and tempo setting.
It suits someone who wants to try many full tracks and keep the MP3s, and will pay before using them in business. I tested on the free plan, signed in with Google, with no card. Six tests are graded.
My pick for music you want to edit note by note. AIVA's composer let me set the key, length and tempo and open the track in a note-level editor, and the free plan gave MP3 and MIDI files. But free songs are personal use with a credit line.
Video review · 5:32
AIVA has two parts. The Create page turned a prompt into a 3:38 pop song in 92.2 seconds and a 0:25 lo-fi beat in 19.5. The older composer builds from over 250 styles; I set the key to C minor and changed the tempo from 80 to 100 in the editor.
Free songs carry a personal-use licence and a credit line, and AIVA owns their copyright until the Pro plan. WAV and stems are greyed out on free, and the composer allows 3 downloads a month. The billing page says Standard tracks are owned by you, which the help article does not.
It suits someone who wants to shape a piece of music, not just receive it, and will pay before publishing. I tested on the free plan, signed in with Google: four songs on the Create page and one in the composer. Seven tests are graded.
My pick for hearing ideas before you pay. AirMusic returned two songs per press, in 38.3 and 60.7 seconds on the two runs I timed, and offers seven models in one menu. But the free plan cannot download anything, and 25 credits pay for five generations.
Video review · 4:51
AirMusic gave me two songs from every press: eight songs from four generations, at 5 credits each. Two timed runs took 38.3 and 60.7 seconds, for songs of 2:53 and 3:00, then 1:24 and 1:20. It lists seven models and a set of editing tools.
The free plan cannot download: the button opens a dialog titled "Downloading songs requires a plan", so I could measure no file and audio quality is not graded. The stem splitter costs 25 credits, the whole free allowance, and songs are kept for 30 days.
It suits someone who wants to hear what the models can do and will pay before they need a file or business use. Free music is personal use only. I tested on the free plan, signed in with Google, with 25 credits. Five tests are graded.
My pick for clear ownership wording. The terms say you fully own the output and may publish and monetize it, and one press made two songs of 3:02 and 3:07 with lyrics. But the free plan pays for one generation a month, and downloads cost credits.
Video review · 3:54
MusicAI wrote lyrics from one prompt and returned two songs of 3:02 and 3:07, listed no later than 74 seconds after the press. Its terms call the music "100% Royalty-Free" and say you fully own the rights, with no attribution rule. The Remix menu lists Cover, Extend, Replace Section and Mashup.
The free plan has 2.5 credits a month, a generation costs 2 and a download costs 2, so the 0.5 left could not save a file and audio quality is not graded. The commercial licence certificate is included with annual plans only, and Batch Download is greyed out.
It suits someone who wants to hear a full song before paying and will take a yearly plan before they need a file. I tested on the free plan, signed in with Google, with no card. Five tests are graded.
My pick for a preview before the song ends. BeMusic showed a playable preview of both songs after about 48 seconds and returned songs of 3:38 and 3:05. But the free plan blocked the MP3 download, and its free credit figures disagree.
Video review · 3:20
One press of Generate gave two songs, 3:38 and 3:05, for 20 credits on the BeMusic Lite model. A playable preview of both showed after about 48 seconds and the finished songs after about 108. The share link worked, and the library keeps songs for 7 days on Free.
The free plan then blocked the MP3 download behind a window that says "Unlock MP3 downloads", so audio quality is not graded. The pricing page lists 30 one-time credits for Free while the generator page shows a 3-day trial of 20 credits a day, and the commercial licence starts at Pro.
It suits someone who wants to hear a song before paying and will subscribe before they need a file. Free output is licensed for personal, non-commercial use. I tested on the free plan, signed in with Google, with no card. Five tests are graded.
My pick for a free song with written lyrics. MakeBestMusic returned two songs of 3:56 and 3:37 in about 90 seconds, with lyrics it wrote itself. But the free plan blocked the MP3 download, and its 6 credits pay for two generations.
Video review · 3:46
MakeBestMusic wrote lyrics and returned two songs of 3:56 and 3:37 from one press, listed within about 90 seconds. The Edit menu opens ReCreate and Reference on the free plan, and the free plan includes 2 AI lyric generations a day.
The MP3 download opened a window headed "Unlock All Features" with the line "Exclusive benefit for subscribers", and no file came, so audio quality is not graded. Inpaint, Translate Track and Change Voice carry a crown, songs are stored for 7 days on free, and the Create button shows no credit price.
It suits someone who wants to hear a song before paying and will subscribe before they need a file. The pricing page says every plan grants full commercial rights, but the Free card lists no licence. I tested on the free plan with 6 credits. Five tests are graded.
The ten above in one table: the measured average, my verdict, the final grade, and every test grade behind it.
| Rank | Tool | Price from | Test average | My verdict | Final grade | Tier |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Eleven Music | $6/mo | 3.79 of 10 tests | +0.8 | 4.5/5 | Excellent |
| 2 | OpenMusic AI | $10.49/mo | 3.25 of 10 tests | +0.2 | 3.4/5 | Average |
| 3 | Somio AI | $9.99/mo | 3.06 of 10 tests | +0.2 | 3.2/5 | Average |
| 4 | Loudly | $8/mo | 2.86 of 10 tests | +0.4 | 3.2/5 | Average |
| 5 | MiniMax Music | $4.50/mo | 2.76 of 10 tests | +0.5 | 3.2/5 | Average |
| 6 | AIVA | $11/mo | 2.67 of 10 tests | +0.4 | 3.0/5 | Average |
| 7 | AirMusic | $11.90/mo | 2.45 of 10 tests | +0.2 | 2.6/5 | Average |
| 8 | MusicAI | $8.33/mo | 2.45 of 10 tests | 0.0 | 2.4/5 | Below average |
| 9 | BeMusic | $7.20/mo | 2.25 of 10 tests | 0.0 | 2.2/5 | Below average |
| 10 | MakeBestMusic | $14.90/mo | 2.25 of 10 tests | 0.0 | 2.2/5 | Below average |
Before I opened any generator I wrote 12 prompts: a road-trip pop song, a lo-fi beat at about 70 BPM, a chase cue, an EDM drop and a Spanish reggaeton among them. I pasted each one in once, kept the first track, saved the audio where the plan allowed it, timed every generation and measured the files instead of trusting my ears. Up to ten tests, graded 1 to 5; the grade is their average plus my verdict, which can move it by up to one point. A test a free plan could not reach gets no grade, and each review says how many tests its grade rests on. Every prompt, timing and measurement sits in the test results linked from each review.
| Test | What I do | Example: Eleven Music (#1) | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|
| Audio Quality & Fidelity | Save every track and measure it: format, loudness, clipping, endings. | Stereo AAC at about 128 kbps; 4 of 12 peaks above full scale | 4/5 |
| Prompt Adherence | Check each track against its prompt: genre, mood, tempo, instruments. | 9 of 12 prompts fully met; tempo right on 10 of 11 | 4/5 |
| Vocals & Lyrics | Check the sung words of the four vocal prompts against the lyrics. | 94 percent of the Spanish words heard; the folk ballad had no words | 3/5 |
| Musical Coherence & Structure | Check every track for a clear structure and a proper ending. | 4 of 12 tracks stop dead at 30 seconds; 6 fade out | 4/5 |
| Length & Customisation Control | A ten-point checklist: length, tempo, key, instruments, structure. | 7 of 10 points worked | 3/5 |
| Editing, Stems & Regeneration | A ten-point checklist: regenerate, extend, replace a section, stems. | 5 of 10 points worked; stems need a paid plan | 2/5 |
| Format, Download & Export | A ten-point checklist: file formats, quality, stems, ways to share. | Not graded: the free plan gives no download | |
| Commercial-Use Rights & Licensing | Read the licence on the tested plan: who owns it, where it may be used. | Free use is personal only; Starter adds commercial use | 4/5 |
| Generation Speed | Time every generation from pressing create to a playable track. | Median 4.2 seconds per 30-second track; slowest 7.0 | 5/5 |
| Free-Tier Limits & Pricing | Use the free plan until it stops. Read every plan at the checkout. | 10,000 free credits a month; 450 per 30-second track | 4/5 |
Every measured grade comes from a tool I built and ran on every builder the same way. Each has its own page with how it works and the figure it gave every review.
You can see all the checkers I built on the checkers page.
| Tool | What it does | Reviews graded |
|---|---|---|
| Track timer | Presses Generate on a fixed prompt and times how long the first finished track takes, and what it cost in credits. | 10 |
| Track analyser | Measures a downloaded track: format, bit rate, loudness, peak level, clipping, silence at each end and tempo. | 9 |
| Music prompt set | Gives every AI music generator the same 12 written prompts, each naming a genre, a mood, a tempo and instruments. | 1 |
| Music generation timer | Times every track from pressing Generate to the finished track on the tool's own list, and reads the credit balance before and after. | 10 |
| Music audio analyser | Measures every saved track: bit rate, loudness, peak level, clipping, the highest frequency with content, tempo and how the ending behaves. | 6 |
| Music lyric check | Compares the words sung in a track with the lyrics the tool wrote for it. | 1 |
These monitors keep measuring the test sites after the review is live. You can see all of them, with their charts, in the monitors lobby.
| Monitor | How often | Builders |
|---|---|---|
| Uptime monitor | Every 5 minutes | 25 |
| Page speed tests | Every day | 23 |
| Security and privacy checks | Every day | 25 |
| Price tracker | Every day | 130 |
The place on this page is the headline grade of the review, highest first. When two tools share a grade, the higher measured score goes first, then the name. The grade words mean: 4.5 and up excellent, 3.5 to 4.4 good, 2.5 to 3.4 average, under 2.5 below average or poor.
The full procedure is on the AI music generators methodology page, and every tool I test with is on the checkers page.
Check what the free plan really pays for before you start, because on some tools the credits cover only one song. Try the download button early: on some it did nothing or asked for a subscription. Read the licence, since several tools say they keep rights to what they make. Check how long free songs are kept, because some are deleted within days. Expect some waits to be long, and listen to the ending, because some tracks stop dead at the length limit.
Ten generators, the same fixed prompts, the same tests wherever a free plan allowed. One came out on top.
Eleven Music won because it was fast, matched what I asked for and let me edit. It was the only free plan that let me run nine of the ten tests. I made all 12 prompts, every song comes with a written plan of sections and lyrics, and I could re-roll one section, add a section and write an edit, each in under 9 seconds.
It is not perfect. The free plan gave me no download, so I measured the audio from the stream the player loads. Free music is for personal use only, stems need a paid plan, and the grade leaves out the export test. Pay before you rely on a track, and read the terms of the plan you buy. I ran every test on the free plan.

The other nine are in the complete rankings, each with a one-line verdict on its card.
Eleven Music ranks first at 4.5 out of 5 in my tests. OpenMusic AI (3.4) and Somio AI (3.2) follow.
OpenMusic AI, at 3.4 out of 5, is the highest-ranked AI music generator here whose own pricing page offers a free plan (free plan with 30 credits a year). Loudly (3.2), MiniMax Music (3.2), AIVA (3.0), AirMusic (2.6), MusicAI (2.4), BeMusic (2.2), MakeBestMusic (2.2) also have a free plan. A free trial that ends, or a plan that needs a card up front, does not count as free.
Mostly not. Eleven Music says free use is personal only; its Starter plan allows commercial use without streaming, and release to Spotify and Apple starts at Creator. Loudly and AirMusic say non-commercial. AIVA allows free songs for non-commercial use with a credit to AIVA, and the copyright is yours from the Pro plan. MusicAI's terms call its music royalty-free and eligible for commercial use, but the licence certificate is for annual plans only. OpenMusic AI's terms say you own your output, while its pricing page crosses out commercial use on Free. Read the terms of the plan you pay for.
MiniMax Music let me download all 12 tracks as 256 kbps MP3 files at no cost. AIVA saved four songs as 256 kbps MP3 files, and its composer also gave a MIDI file. Somio AI gave a 320 kbps MP3 and Loudly one 192 kbps MP3 a day. Eleven Music, AirMusic, BeMusic and MakeBestMusic gave no file on the free plan. MusicAI and OpenMusic AI charge 2 credits a download, and I did not download from either.
Each tool's grade is the average of the same 10 tests, run by hand on sites I published, plus my verdict, which can move it by up to one point and is explained on every review. The list is in grade order, highest first; a tie goes to the higher measured score. The full procedure is on the AI music generators methodology page.
Written by Miles Foster, Owner and tester, RankDude.