Test log
MakeBestMusic test data
Raw results for the MakeBestMusic review. The verdict is in the review.
- Tested
- 7 November 2026
- Tester
- Miles Foster
- Account
- Free demo account, signed up by RankDude, nothing paid to the brand
- Tests
- 10
- Screenshots
- 5
- Method
- Published methodology
- Environment
- Google Chrome on desktop
Results
| ID | Test | Key measurement | Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| T01 | Audio Quality & Fidelity | – | n/a |
| T02 | Prompt Adherence | – | n/a |
| T03 | Vocals & Lyrics | – | n/a |
| T04 | Musical Coherence & Structure | – | n/a |
| T05 | Length & Customisation Control | – | n/a |
| T06 | Editing, Stems & Regeneration | Points passed: 2 of 10 | 1/5 |
| T07 | Format, Download & Export | Points passed: 0 of 10 | 1/5 |
| T08 | Commercial-Use Rights & Licensing | Certificate on free: No | 3/5 |
| T09 | Generation Speed | Time to finished songs: 90 s or less | 3/5 |
| T10 | Free-Tier Limits & Pricing | Free credits: 6 | 3/5 |
| Overall (in the review) | 2.2/5 | ||
Audio Quality & Fidelity
n/aNot Tested- Method
- A downloaded track is read for format, bit rate, loudness, peak and tempo.
- Remark
- Not graded: the free plan would not let me download a file, so there was nothing to measure.
Raw notes
A downloaded track is read for format, bit rate, loudness, peak and tempo.
Not run.
- Run on a paid plan.
Prompt Adherence
n/aNot Tested- Method
- Each track is checked against genre, mood, tempo and named instruments.
- Remark
- Not graded: one generation cannot score twelve prompts on four points each.
Raw notes
Each track is checked against genre, mood, tempo and named instruments.
Not run.
- Run on a paid plan with all twelve prompts.
Vocals & Lyrics
n/aNot Tested- Method
- The four vocal prompts are marked for tune, words and language.
- Remark
- Not graded: I could not check the singing word by word, and no file could be downloaded.
Raw notes
The four vocal prompts are marked for tune, words and language.
Not run.
- Run on a paid plan, with the Spanish prompt.
Musical Coherence & Structure
n/aNot Tested- Method
- Every track is checked from start to finish for structure and endings.
- Remark
- Not graded: two tracks from one prompt are not enough to judge structure.
Raw notes
Every track is checked from start to finish for structure and endings.
Not run.
- Run on a paid plan.
Length & Customisation Control
n/aNot Tested- Method
- Ten controls are used on the test date and each must change the result.
- Remark
- Not graded: the controls were seen but none could be run on the credits left.
Raw notes
Ten controls are used on the test date and each must change the result.
Not run.
- Run on a paid plan.
Editing, Stems & Regeneration
1/5Tested- Method
- The track menu, its Edit submenu, the Extend panel, the Split Music page and the Music Mastering page were opened on the finished generation, and each of the ten points was checked on the free account.
- Points passed
- 2 of 10
- Credits for stems
- 5
- Remark
- Scale 1: two points worked on the free account. Several more are offered but I did not run them, so they are not counted.
Raw notes
The track menu, its Edit submenu, the Extend panel, the Split Music page and the Music Mastering page were opened on the finished generation, and each of the ten points was checked on the free account. A point counts only when it worked.
Several takes at once: yes, one press of Create gave two songs.
History: yes, the workspace keeps the songs; the free plan lists "Music Cloud Storage: 7 Days".
Edit submenu: "ReCreate" and "Reference" are open; "Inpaint", "Translate Track", "Change Voice" and "Make Persona" carry a crown, the sign of a paid feature.
Extend opens a panel with "Extend from" a time box; I did not run it, because it costs credits.
Stems: the Split Music page shows 5 credits for up to five stems, and I had 3 left. Mastering shows 3 credits.
Inpaint, the tool that replaces a section in place, carries a crown. Trim and mix levels: not found.
- ReCreate, Extend, Split and Mastering were not run, to stay under the credit stop line.
- Paid plans were not bought, so the locked tools were not tested.
- A first share of a song was offered for 3 more credits; not taken, so no extend or re-create on them.
Format, Download & Export
1/5Tested- Method
- "Download MP3" was pressed on the first finished song, and the result was recorded.
- Points passed
- 0 of 10
- Free downloads
- 0
- Remark
- Scale 1: no export worked on the free account.
Raw notes
"Download MP3" was pressed on the first finished song, and the result was recorded.
MP3: pressed, and a window titled "Unlock All Features" opened with the message "Exclusive benefit for subscribers". No file came.
WAV: marked with a crown in the menu.
The pricing page lists "Download MP3, WAV" and "Unlimited Download" for Basic and above, and none for Free.
MIDI is a separate tool costing 2 credits; a bit rate choice and a batch download: not found.
A share icon sits beside each song; I did not test it.
- A paid plan lists MP3 and WAV; neither was tested.
Commercial-Use Rights & Licensing
3/5Tested- Method
- The terms of service (makebestmusic.com/terms, read 7 November 2026, marked "Last modified: October 22, 2026") and the pricing page were read for ownership, commercial use, streaming and the free plan.
- Certificate on free
- No
- Cheapest plan with it
- Basic
- Remark
- Scale 3: the page promises commercial rights, the certificate is a paid feature, and the terms leave ownership vague.
Raw notes
The terms of service (makebestmusic.com/terms, read 7 November 2026, marked "Last modified: October 22, 2026") and the pricing page were read for ownership, commercial use, streaming and the free plan.
The pricing page says "Every MakeBestMusic plan grants full commercial rights", but the Free card lists no licence.
The track menu item "Commercial License" carries a crown on the free plan.
The FAQ says that during a subscription period you can "download the commercial license certificate", and that it stops once the plan ends.
Terms: "Ownership of AI-generated content is determined by your subscription plan." The terms do not say what each plan gives.
The terms say you are "responsible for ensuring your generated content does not violate third-party rights".
- Terms read by me, not a lawyer.
- The certificate was not seen, because no plan was bought.
Generation Speed
3/5Tested- Method
- One generation was timed from pressing Create For Free to the finished songs, on one connection, with the credit counter read before and after.
- Time to finished songs
- 90 s or less
- Songs per press
- 2
- Credits per press
- 3
- Remark
- Scale 3: between one and two minutes. This is one generation, so the median is that one time.
Raw notes
One generation was timed from pressing Create For Free to the finished songs, on one connection, with the credit counter read before and after.
The counter fell from 6 to 3 within 2.1 seconds of the press.
Two placeholders with the song title and "--:--" showed at 22.6 seconds.
The durations 03:56 and 03:37 showed on the next check, at 89.9 seconds.
The button read "Create For Free" and showed no credit price.
- One generation on a free queue, which may differ from the priority queue on paid plans.
Free-Tier Limits & Pricing
3/5Tested- Method
- The free plan was used until a second generation would have passed 85 percent of its 6 credits.
- Free credits
- 6
- Cheapest paid plan
- $14.90 a month yearly
- Remark
- Scale 3: a tight free tier with no downloads, and a paid plan between $12 and $20 a month.
Raw notes
The free plan was used until a second generation would have passed 85 percent of its 6 credits. The pricing page was read in both billing views on 7 November 2026.
Free: no card, 6 credits, "2 Free AI Lyric Generations Daily", "Music Cloud Storage: 7 Days", no download.
Basic: $19.90 a month, or $14.90 a month paid yearly, 200 credits a month.
Standard: $39.90 a month, or $29.90 a month paid yearly, 600 credits a month.
Professional: $169.90 a month, or $129.80 a month paid yearly, unlimited credits.
At 3 credits for two songs, 200 credits is about 66 presses and 133 songs: about $0.11 a song on Basic billed yearly.
- No plan was bought, so the checkout, renewal and cancellation were not tested.
Coverage
Tested
- One Simple-mode generation with the fixed pop prompt, timed from the Create button
- The track menu, the download menu and the download window
- The Extend panel, opened but not run
- The Custom page controls, the pricing page in both billing views and the terms of service
Not tested or limited
- The free plan's 6 credits paid for one generation, so only one of the twelve fixed prompts was run
- The workspace offered 3 credits for a first share of a song; I did not take it, so no second generation, re-create or extend was run on those credits
- The MP3 download is blocked on the free plan, so no file was measured and audio quality is left out
- Re-create, extend, split (5 credits) and mastering (3 credits) cost credits and were not run
- The singing was not checked word by word, so the vocal test is left out
- No plan was bought: WAV, the commercial licence certificate and cancellation were not tested
Still to test
- All twelve prompts, with the singing and the Spanish prompt, on a paid plan
- A downloaded MP3 and WAV measured
- Extend, re-create, split and mastering
- The commercial licence certificate and cancellation