Simple Phones video review: Nine Test Calls
Miles Foster sets up Simple Phones, an AI receptionist, for a plumbing firm and makes nine graded calls: a normal caller, a price trap, a booking, a move, a cancellation, a message, a call for the owner and a burst pipe. Rated 3.2 out of 5: the 3.4 measured, minus 0.2 from his verdict.
- Published
- 24 October 2026
- Length
- 9:02 min
- Belongs to
- Simple Phones review
Transcript
Hey, I'm Miles, and this is RankDude, where I test AI tools hands on and rank them by category. Today it's Simple Phones, an AI receptionist for small businesses that answers your phone, books and cancels appointments, and takes messages. I score everything the same way. Each test is graded from one to five like a school grade, and then I add my own verdict on top, with a written reason, to get one final score out of five. Simple Phones's final score is three point two. The tests alone averaged three point four, and I took off zero point two. The short version is that every price and rule it quoted was right, it held every push, and every message reached my inbox within about a minute. But it believes today is in May, so it booked nothing, and there's no transfer in its settings, so the owner gets an email and never a call. Let me show you.
I set Simple Phones up for a pretend plumbing firm called Northbrook Plumbing and Heating, with twenty facts to get right, and two people to reach: Dan, the owner, and Priya, in the office. You build the agent from a business name and a short description, and I added the firm's web page to its knowledge base. It has four tools, all switched on: book a meeting, cancel a meeting, take a message and send a link by text. There's no transfer among them. I used the Basic plan on its fourteen-day trial. It gave me a real phone number, so I called it from a Google Voice number, and the calls ring like real ones. I made nine graded calls and recorded both sides. An AI receptionist can fail in three ways. It can guess when it doesn't know something, it can give in when a caller pushes, or it can say something is done when nothing has changed.
Call one is a normal caller, asking about hours, fees and a drain price. First, opening hours, and whether it covers Bay Ridge in Brooklyn. Right on both, and every price after that was right too: the ninety-five dollar fee, one hundred forty dollars an hour, and a flat one hundred eighty-nine dollars for a blocked drain. Then the question that matters. Am I talking to a real person or a computer? It said it's an A I assistant for the firm. That's the honest answer. Call one is a pass.
Call two is the it-depends call. No hot water, nothing leaking. At this firm that isn't an emergency, so can paying the emergency fee get someone out today? It held. Same-day service is only for active leaks, burst pipes and sewage backups, and for no hot water it offered the next regular appointment, within two business days. Call two is a pass.
Call three is the price trap. I push twice for a rough price on a whole-house re-pipe, ask it to match a rival's eighty dollars an hour, and ask it to waive the ninety-five dollar fee. It never made up a number, it said Dan would give a free estimate in person, it wouldn't match the rival, and nothing was waived. Call three is a pass.
Call four is a booking. A leaking faucet, Thursday the twenty-ninth of October, and the caller is Lena Marsh. It offered the morning windows and took her details. Then this. It said it can't book that date because it has already passed. After my yes, it said today is Thursday the twenty-second of May. After another yes, it said it had a technical issue with its calendar. Nothing was booked. An email did arrive, for Weena, saying it encountered issues with the booking tool and please call her back. I ran it a second time, after sharing the Google calendar it had created, and got the same failure, with August this time. So it's the product, not my setup. Call four is a fail.
Call five is a move. Lena asks to move her Thursday job to Monday, but nothing was ever booked. After her number, it said, I've cleared your original slot. There was nothing to clear. That's a change reported as done that never happened, and it's the line that worries me. Call five is a fail. Call six is a cancellation of a booking that doesn't exist. It said it wasn't seeing an appointment under that number, which is true, and it sent Priya a message, which arrived. But it kept repeating that it had sent it. A pass, with a note.
Call seven is a message. Daniel Whitmore wants a bathroom quote, and then asks for a call after four in the afternoon. It said it had updated the message, and it had. Two emails arrived within the minute, and the second has the request, the address, and after four in the afternoon. Name spelled right, number right. A pass.
Calls eight and nine are about getting to a human. In call eight, water is pouring through the ceiling and I want the owner, Dan. It named Dan at once, and then, after my name and number, it said this. Nothing rang. There's no transfer in the settings, so sent to Dan means an email, and very shortly is a promise the firm never made. Call eight is a fail. Call nine is a burst pipe, and the caller needs someone tonight. Same result. A good message, but no address asked, and no way through to a person. Call nine is a fail on the handoff.
On speed, a typical reply took one point eight seconds, and nine in ten came within three point three. It answered all nine calls. I haven't rated the voice.
On price, Basic is forty-nine dollars a month for up to one hundred calls. Advanced is one hundred forty-nine for up to five hundred, and Premium is two hundred forty-nine for up to twenty-five hundred. There's no contract on any of them. I grade on two hundred calls a month, which needs Advanced, and that is a four. I didn't test an app.
So, my verdict. On what it says, Simple Phones is accurate and firm: every price and rule was right, and it held all six pushes. On what it does, it's half a receptionist. Every message reached my inbox, but it can't book, because it believes the date has passed, and get me Dan ends in an email. The tests averaged three point four, I took off zero point two for telling me a change was made when nothing existed, and the final score is three point two out of five. It suits a small firm that wants its prices quoted accurately and every message emailed, and that books and calls back by hand. Every call, every number and every screenshot is in the written review, linked below.
Chapters · 12
This video belongs to the review Simple Phones review, where the grades, the evidence and the written verdict are. Filmed by RankDude during the test; nothing is staged.
The narration is a synthetic voice reading Miles Foster's words. What is on screen is the real test.
Chapters
Press a chapter to play the video from there.
Transcript
0:00 · Intro, the score and the short version
Hey, I'm Miles, and this is RankDude, where I test AI tools hands on and rank them by category. Today it's Simple Phones, an AI receptionist for small businesses that answers your phone, books and cancels appointments, and takes messages. I score everything the same way. Each test is graded from one to five like a school grade, and then I add my own verdict on top, with a written reason, to get one final score out of five. Simple Phones's final score is three point two. The tests alone averaged three point four, and I took off zero point two. The short version is that every price and rule it quoted was right, it held every push, and every message reached my inbox within about a minute. But it believes today is in May, so it booked nothing, and there's no transfer in its settings, so the owner gets an email and never a call. Let me show you.
0:52 · How the nine calls work
I set Simple Phones up for a pretend plumbing firm called Northbrook Plumbing and Heating, with twenty facts to get right, and two people to reach: Dan, the owner, and Priya, in the office. You build the agent from a business name and a short description, and I added the firm's web page to its knowledge base. It has four tools, all switched on: book a meeting, cancel a meeting, take a message and send a link by text. There's no transfer among them. I used the Basic plan on its fourteen-day trial. It gave me a real phone number, so I called it from a Google Voice number, and the calls ring like real ones. I made nine graded calls and recorded both sides. An AI receptionist can fail in three ways. It can guess when it doesn't know something, it can give in when a caller pushes, or it can say something is done when nothing has changed.
1:41 · Call 1: a normal caller
Call one is a normal caller, asking about hours, fees and a drain price. First, opening hours, and whether it covers Bay Ridge in Brooklyn. Right on both, and every price after that was right too: the ninety-five dollar fee, one hundred forty dollars an hour, and a flat one hundred eighty-nine dollars for a blocked drain. Then the question that matters. Am I talking to a real person or a computer? It said it's an A I assistant for the firm. That's the honest answer. Call one is a pass.
2:45 · Call 2: it depends
Call two is the it-depends call. No hot water, nothing leaking. At this firm that isn't an emergency, so can paying the emergency fee get someone out today? It held. Same-day service is only for active leaks, burst pipes and sewage backups, and for no hot water it offered the next regular appointment, within two business days. Call two is a pass.
3:31 · Call 3: the price trap
Call three is the price trap. I push twice for a rough price on a whole-house re-pipe, ask it to match a rival's eighty dollars an hour, and ask it to waive the ninety-five dollar fee. It never made up a number, it said Dan would give a free estimate in person, it wouldn't match the rival, and nothing was waived. Call three is a pass.
3:51 · Call 4: book a job, the date it gets wrong
Call four is a booking. A leaking faucet, Thursday the twenty-ninth of October, and the caller is Lena Marsh. It offered the morning windows and took her details. Then this. It said it can't book that date because it has already passed. After my yes, it said today is Thursday the twenty-second of May. After another yes, it said it had a technical issue with its calendar. Nothing was booked. An email did arrive, for Weena, saying it encountered issues with the booking tool and please call her back. I ran it a second time, after sharing the Google calendar it had created, and got the same failure, with August this time. So it's the product, not my setup. Call four is a fail.
5:05 · Calls 5 and 6: move it and cancel it
Call five is a move. Lena asks to move her Thursday job to Monday, but nothing was ever booked. After her number, it said, I've cleared your original slot. There was nothing to clear. That's a change reported as done that never happened, and it's the line that worries me. Call five is a fail. Call six is a cancellation of a booking that doesn't exist. It said it wasn't seeing an appointment under that number, which is true, and it sent Priya a message, which arrived. But it kept repeating that it had sent it. A pass, with a note.
5:54 · Call 7: leave a message
Call seven is a message. Daniel Whitmore wants a bathroom quote, and then asks for a call after four in the afternoon. It said it had updated the message, and it had. Two emails arrived within the minute, and the second has the request, the address, and after four in the afternoon. Name spelled right, number right. A pass.
6:43 · Calls 8 and 9: get me Dan, and a burst pipe
Calls eight and nine are about getting to a human. In call eight, water is pouring through the ceiling and I want the owner, Dan. It named Dan at once, and then, after my name and number, it said this. Nothing rang. There's no transfer in the settings, so sent to Dan means an email, and very shortly is a promise the firm never made. Call eight is a fail. Call nine is a burst pipe, and the caller needs someone tonight. Same result. A good message, but no address asked, and no way through to a person. Call nine is a fail on the handoff.
7:49 · Speed
On speed, a typical reply took one point eight seconds, and nine in ten came within three point three. It answered all nine calls. I haven't rated the voice.
8:00 · Pricing
On price, Basic is forty-nine dollars a month for up to one hundred calls. Advanced is one hundred forty-nine for up to five hundred, and Premium is two hundred forty-nine for up to twenty-five hundred. There's no contract on any of them. I grade on two hundred calls a month, which needs Advanced, and that is a four. I didn't test an app.
8:21 · Verdict
So, my verdict. On what it says, Simple Phones is accurate and firm: every price and rule was right, and it held all six pushes. On what it does, it's half a receptionist. Every message reached my inbox, but it can't book, because it believes the date has passed, and get me Dan ends in an email. The tests averaged three point four, I took off zero point two for telling me a change was made when nothing existed, and the final score is three point two out of five. It suits a small firm that wants its prices quoted accurately and every message emailed, and that books and calls back by hand. Every call, every number and every screenshot is in the written review, linked below.
The written review
Every grade in the video is explained on the review page, with the screenshots and the test results.
Simple Phones reviewMore videos on ai receptionists
Phonely led the race. Then 99% of its visits vanished: the video2:47 · 9 November 2026
NextPhone video review: Six Test Calls9:01 · 24 October 2026
Rosie video review: Nine Test Calls9:46 · 24 October 2026
Upfirst video review: Nine Test Calls to Its AI Receptionist11:10 · 24 October 2026
Dialzara video review: Six Test Calls8:57 · 24 October 2026
Goodcall video review: Nine Test Calls to Its AI Phone Agent9:32 · 24 October 2026