Upfirst video review: Nine Test Calls to Its AI Receptionist
Miles Foster sets up Upfirst for a plumbing firm and makes nine graded calls: a normal caller, a price trap, a booking, a move, a cancellation, a message, a call for the owner and an emergency with nobody answering. Rated 4.3 out of 5: the 3.6 measured plus 0.7 from his verdict.
- Published
- 24 October 2026
- Length
- 11:10 min
- Belongs to
- Upfirst review
Transcript
Hey, I'm Miles, and this is RankDude, where I test AI tools hands on and rank them by category. Today it's Upfirst, an AI receptionist for small businesses that answers your phone, books jobs into your calendar and puts urgent calls through to a person. I score everything the same way. There's a set of tests, each graded from one to five like a school grade, and then I add my own verdict on top, with a written reason, to get one final score out of five. Upfirst's final score is four point three out of five. The tests alone averaged three point six, and I added zero point seven. The short version is that every price it gave was right, it held every price trap, and when I asked, it said plainly that it's an automated receptionist. But it told one caller her appointment was moved, and then cancelled, and the calendar didn't change either time. Let me show you.
I set Upfirst up for a pretend plumbing firm called Northbrook Plumbing and Heating, with twenty facts to get right, a price list, and two people to put calls through to: Dan, the owner, and Priya, in billing. I typed the price list into its setup wizard, and it turned it into six items and kept every fact. Upfirst gives you a real phone number, so I called it from a Google Voice number that I pay ten dollars a month for, and the calls ring like real ones. I made nine graded calls, each one built to find a single failure. An AI receptionist can fail in three ways. It can guess when it doesn't know something, it can give in when a caller pushes, or it can say something is done when nothing has changed.
Call one is a normal caller, asking about opening hours, what it costs just to come out, and the hourly rate. Every price was right, and so was Saturday, and it said Bay Ridge is covered. Then I asked the question that matters. It said it's an automated receptionist. That's the honest answer, and not every receptionist gives it.
Call two is the it-depends call. The caller has had no hot water since the morning, nothing is leaking, and they ask if that counts as an emergency. At this firm, it doesn't. It got it right. No hot water is a regular visit, not an emergency. I even asked if I could pay the emergency fee to get someone today, and it didn't promise a same-day visit. It offered Monday, and booked the first morning.
Call three is the price trap. A whole-house re-pipe isn't on the price list, so I push for a rough number, then I ask it to match a rival's rate and to waive the fee. It never made up a number, it never matched the rival and it never waived the fee. One slip: it added a rule that isn't in the price list, that the diagnostic fee applies if the firm comes out and doesn't do the work. That's the one invented answer I found.
Now booking, which is where it gets interesting. I connected a Google Calendar and made one appointment type, a two-hour plumbing visit. Call four asks for a faucet repair on Wednesday morning. It offered eight or ten, I took ten, and it landed on the calendar with the number, the address and the problem. One oddity: the name on it is the earlier caller's, because Upfirst recognised my number. Call five is the same caller ringing back to move the job to Monday, which is Dan's day off. It said the faucet repair is now set for Monday, and that the Wednesday appointment had been cancelled. I checked the calendar twice. Wednesday was still there, and Monday was empty. Call six is the cancellation. It said the appointment was already cancelled. It wasn't. Its own summary repeats the false version, so you'd only catch this by opening the calendar. That's two fails, and they're the same fail: it says it did something it didn't.
Call seven is a message. Daniel Whitmore wants a quote for a bathroom rough-in, spells his surname, gives a number and an address, and asks for a call after four. That works well. About forty seconds after the call, an email arrived with a plain summary, the address, the number, the after four note, a button for the recording and the whole transcript. Both messages I graded were complete and right.
Calls eight and nine are about getting to a human. In call eight, water is coming through the ceiling and the caller wants the owner. It named Dan in its first reply and tried to connect him, with no questions first. I'd pointed the transfer at a number nobody answers, so it came back and took a message, though it made up an excuse, that Dan might be with another caller. Call nine is a burst pipe at night, same setup. Same pattern, and this time it took the name, the number and the address. The very first time I made this call, the transfer was real. It rang my phone, it briefed me before connecting the call, and that's the hand-over working the way it should.
On speed, it's slow. A typical reply took about three seconds, and one in ten took more than six. It answered every call, and the greeting started about six seconds after I pressed call, ringing included. The voice is clear. Every price and phone number came out cleanly. But it sounds generic and robotic, and I rate it three out of five.
I went through every default, the way I do for every receptionist. Its own greeting was close, but I replaced it with the firm's. It asked every caller for an email address, which the firm doesn't need, so I switched that off. There's no opening hours setting, so it answers the same at any hour. And I made a mistake of my own. I'd marked Dan's day off as free on the calendar, so it booked a visit onto that Monday. I fixed that before the move call, and it still offered Monday.
On price, Upfirst charges by the call. Twenty-four ninety-five a month for thirty calls, fifty-nine ninety-five for ninety, one hundred fifty-nine ninety-five for three hundred, and about three hundred dollars for six hundred. Two hundred calls a month fit on the Pro plan, at one hundred fifty-nine ninety-five. The fourteen-day trial is free, and takes no card. Is there an app? No. I found none in the App Store or Google Play. It runs in the browser, and the dashboard works on a phone.
So, my verdict. On what it says, Upfirst is honest. Every price was right, it held every trap, and it admitted it's automated. On what it does, it falls short: the move and the cancellation were announced and never made. The tests averaged three point six, I added zero point seven, and the final score is four point three out of five. A good fit if you check your own calendar and handle booking changes by hand. Every call, every number and every screenshot is in the written review, linked below.
Chapters · 12
This video belongs to the review Upfirst review, where the grades, the evidence and the written verdict are. Filmed by RankDude during the test; nothing is staged.
The narration is a synthetic voice reading Miles Foster's words. What is on screen is the real test.
Chapters
Press a chapter to play the video from there.
Transcript
0:00 · Intro, the score and the short version
Hey, I'm Miles, and this is RankDude, where I test AI tools hands on and rank them by category. Today it's Upfirst, an AI receptionist for small businesses that answers your phone, books jobs into your calendar and puts urgent calls through to a person. I score everything the same way. There's a set of tests, each graded from one to five like a school grade, and then I add my own verdict on top, with a written reason, to get one final score out of five. Upfirst's final score is four point three out of five. The tests alone averaged three point six, and I added zero point seven. The short version is that every price it gave was right, it held every price trap, and when I asked, it said plainly that it's an automated receptionist. But it told one caller her appointment was moved, and then cancelled, and the calendar didn't change either time. Let me show you.
0:53 · How the nine calls work
I set Upfirst up for a pretend plumbing firm called Northbrook Plumbing and Heating, with twenty facts to get right, a price list, and two people to put calls through to: Dan, the owner, and Priya, in billing. I typed the price list into its setup wizard, and it turned it into six items and kept every fact. Upfirst gives you a real phone number, so I called it from a Google Voice number that I pay ten dollars a month for, and the calls ring like real ones. I made nine graded calls, each one built to find a single failure. An AI receptionist can fail in three ways. It can guess when it doesn't know something, it can give in when a caller pushes, or it can say something is done when nothing has changed.
1:34 · Call 1: a normal caller
Call one is a normal caller, asking about opening hours, what it costs just to come out, and the hourly rate. Every price was right, and so was Saturday, and it said Bay Ridge is covered. Then I asked the question that matters. It said it's an automated receptionist. That's the honest answer, and not every receptionist gives it.
2:45 · Call 2: it depends
Call two is the it-depends call. The caller has had no hot water since the morning, nothing is leaking, and they ask if that counts as an emergency. At this firm, it doesn't. It got it right. No hot water is a regular visit, not an emergency. I even asked if I could pay the emergency fee to get someone today, and it didn't promise a same-day visit. It offered Monday, and booked the first morning.
3:30 · Call 3: the price trap
Call three is the price trap. A whole-house re-pipe isn't on the price list, so I push for a rough number, then I ask it to match a rival's rate and to waive the fee. It never made up a number, it never matched the rival and it never waived the fee. One slip: it added a rule that isn't in the price list, that the diagnostic fee applies if the firm comes out and doesn't do the work. That's the one invented answer I found.
4:28 · Calls 4 to 6: book, move and cancel
Now booking, which is where it gets interesting. I connected a Google Calendar and made one appointment type, a two-hour plumbing visit. Call four asks for a faucet repair on Wednesday morning. It offered eight or ten, I took ten, and it landed on the calendar with the number, the address and the problem. One oddity: the name on it is the earlier caller's, because Upfirst recognised my number. Call five is the same caller ringing back to move the job to Monday, which is Dan's day off. It said the faucet repair is now set for Monday, and that the Wednesday appointment had been cancelled. I checked the calendar twice. Wednesday was still there, and Monday was empty. Call six is the cancellation. It said the appointment was already cancelled. It wasn't. Its own summary repeats the false version, so you'd only catch this by opening the calendar. That's two fails, and they're the same fail: it says it did something it didn't.
6:51 · Call 7: leave a message
Call seven is a message. Daniel Whitmore wants a quote for a bathroom rough-in, spells his surname, gives a number and an address, and asks for a call after four. That works well. About forty seconds after the call, an email arrived with a plain summary, the address, the number, the after four note, a button for the recording and the whole transcript. Both messages I graded were complete and right.
7:43 · Calls 8 and 9: get me Dan, and nobody answers
Calls eight and nine are about getting to a human. In call eight, water is coming through the ceiling and the caller wants the owner. It named Dan in its first reply and tried to connect him, with no questions first. I'd pointed the transfer at a number nobody answers, so it came back and took a message, though it made up an excuse, that Dan might be with another caller. Call nine is a burst pipe at night, same setup. Same pattern, and this time it took the name, the number and the address. The very first time I made this call, the transfer was real. It rang my phone, it briefed me before connecting the call, and that's the hand-over working the way it should.
9:21 · Speed and voice
On speed, it's slow. A typical reply took about three seconds, and one in ten took more than six. It answered every call, and the greeting started about six seconds after I pressed call, ringing included. The voice is clear. Every price and phone number came out cleanly. But it sounds generic and robotic, and I rate it three out of five.
9:42 · What I changed
I went through every default, the way I do for every receptionist. Its own greeting was close, but I replaced it with the firm's. It asked every caller for an email address, which the firm doesn't need, so I switched that off. There's no opening hours setting, so it answers the same at any hour. And I made a mistake of my own. I'd marked Dan's day off as free on the calendar, so it booked a visit onto that Monday. I fixed that before the move call, and it still offered Monday.
10:10 · Pricing and the app
On price, Upfirst charges by the call. Twenty-four ninety-five a month for thirty calls, fifty-nine ninety-five for ninety, one hundred fifty-nine ninety-five for three hundred, and about three hundred dollars for six hundred. Two hundred calls a month fit on the Pro plan, at one hundred fifty-nine ninety-five. The fourteen-day trial is free, and takes no card. Is there an app? No. I found none in the App Store or Google Play. It runs in the browser, and the dashboard works on a phone.
10:39 · Verdict
So, my verdict. On what it says, Upfirst is honest. Every price was right, it held every trap, and it admitted it's automated. On what it does, it falls short: the move and the cancellation were announced and never made. The tests averaged three point six, I added zero point seven, and the final score is four point three out of five. A good fit if you check your own calendar and handle booking changes by hand. Every call, every number and every screenshot is in the written review, linked below.
The written review
Every grade in the video is explained on the review page, with the screenshots and the test results.
Upfirst reviewMore videos on ai receptionists
Phonely led the race. Then 99% of its visits vanished: the video2:47 · 9 November 2026
NextPhone video review: Six Test Calls9:01 · 24 October 2026
Rosie video review: Nine Test Calls9:46 · 24 October 2026
Dialzara video review: Six Test Calls8:57 · 24 October 2026
Goodcall video review: Nine Test Calls to Its AI Phone Agent9:32 · 24 October 2026
Marlie video review: Six Test Calls9:02 · 24 October 2026