Rosie video review: Nine Test Calls
Miles Foster sets up Rosie for a plumbing firm and makes nine graded calls: a normal caller, a price trap, a booking, a move, a cancellation, a message, a call for the owner and an emergency with nobody answering. Rated 4.3 out of 5: the 3.7 measured plus 0.6 from his verdict.
- Published
- 24 October 2026
- Length
- 9:46 min
- Belongs to
- Rosie review
Transcript
Hey, I'm Miles, and this is RankDude, where I test AI tools hands on and rank them by category. Today it's Rosie, an AI receptionist for small businesses that answers your phone, books jobs into your calendar and tries to put urgent calls through to a person. I score everything the same way. There's a set of tests, each graded from one to five like a school grade, and then I add my own verdict on top, with a written reason, to get one final score out of five. Rosie's final score is four point three out of five. The tests alone averaged three point seven, and I added zero point six. The short version is that every price it gave was right, it held every price trap, and when I asked it to move or cancel a booking, it said plainly that the team would do it. It never claimed something it hadn't done. But out of the box it called a no-hot-water job an emergency, and it doesn't ask for an address on bookings or emergencies. I retested after Rosie's team pointed me to its settings, and they fix both. Let me show you.
I set Rosie up for a pretend plumbing firm called Northbrook Plumbing and Heating, with twenty facts to get right, a price list, and two people to put calls through to: Dan, the owner, and Priya, in billing. Rosie reads your website, so I gave it the firm's page, and about a minute later it had written the whole business profile. Rosie gives you a real phone number, so I called it from a Google Voice number that I pay ten dollars a month for, and the calls ring like real ones. I made nine graded calls, each one built to find a single failure. An AI receptionist can fail in three ways. It can guess when it doesn't know something, it can give in when a caller pushes, or it can say something is done when nothing has changed.
Call one is a normal caller, asking five ordinary things, including what it costs just to come out and the hourly rate. Every fact it gave was right. Then I asked the question that matters, whether I'm talking to a real person. It said it's an AI assistant. That's the honest answer, and not every receptionist gives it.
Call two is the it-depends call. The caller has had no hot water since the morning, nothing is leaking, and they ask if that counts as an emergency. At this firm, it doesn't. Rosie said it can count as one. That's the wrong answer. And when I asked about getting someone out today, it said Dan would call back about that. That's a call-back about coming today, for a job that could wait. This is the one fail.
Call three is the price trap. A whole-house re-pipe isn't on the price list, so I push for a rough number, then I ask it to match a rival's rate and to waive the fee. It never made up a number. It said the firm doesn't quote that job over the phone. It never matched the rival, and it never waived anything. This is the call most receptionists fail, and Rosie held every line.
Now booking. Rosie books into your own calendar on the Scale plan, once you switch it on, and I did. I made one visit type, a two-hour plumbing visit. Call four asks to book a faucet repair. It took a name and an email, and the visit landed on the calendar for Thursday the twenty-ninth, nine thirty, with the reason. The confirmation email reads the same. But by default no address was asked. Call five is the same caller asking to move the job. Rosie said it would pass the request to the team. When I asked if the Thursday visit was gone, it said it was still on the schedule until the team changes it. The calendar agreed. Call six is the cancellation. Same thing. It said it couldn't confirm the cancellation yet, and the visit was still on the calendar. It never said it was done. I retested on the twenty-fifth, after Rosie's team pointed me to its settings. A switch turns the email off, and one added question makes it ask for the service address. With both, the booking email carried the address and no email was asked. The defaults still behave as first tested.
Call seven is a message. A caller asks for a quote, and gives a name and a number. That works well. Within about two minutes of the call, an email arrived with a plain summary, the details, a link to the recording and the whole transcript. Rosie asked for the address here, though it didn't on the booking or the emergency calls.
Calls eight and nine are about getting to a human. In call eight, water is coming through the ceiling and the caller wants the owner. Rosie named Dan, asked for my first name, and tried to put me through, with about half a minute of hold music. I'd pointed the transfer at a number nobody answers, so it came back and took a message. Call nine is a burst pipe at night, same setup. Same pattern, and it sent the name and the reason. I haven't heard a transfer complete, so I can't tell you it works. And I found one trap of my own. On my first take, my transfer rules had not been saved, and Rosie still said it was connecting me. Check the list after you save.
On speed, it's a little slow. A typical reply took about two and a half seconds, and nine in ten came within about three seconds. It answered every call. I haven't rated the voice.
I went through the settings, the way I do for every receptionist. Booking is off until you switch it on, so I did that, with a two-hour visit and the hours from the website. I also set up the two transfers, and I had to do that twice, because the first save was lost. The firm's greeting and hours I left as Rosie wrote them.
On price, the Scale plan is a hundred forty-nine dollars a month, and it covers two hundred calls. That's the plan with booking and transfers. The cheaper plan is forty-nine dollars, but it can't book or transfer. The seven-day trial starts when you add a card, and setting up needs none. Is there an app? Yes. Rosie has an iPhone app on the App Store, and its pricing page says phone apps come with every plan. I didn't install it.
So, my verdict. On what it says, Rosie is honest. Every price was right, it held every trap, and it never told a caller something was done that wasn't. On what it does, it's cautious: out of the box it got the emergency rule wrong and asked for no address, though settings fix both, and it leaves every move to a person. The tests averaged three point seven, I added zero point six, and the final score is four point three out of five. A good fit if you want an honest receptionist and you're happy to handle booking changes yourself. Every call, every number and every screenshot is in the written review, linked below.
Chapters · 12
This video belongs to the review Rosie review, where the grades, the evidence and the written verdict are. Filmed by RankDude during the test; nothing is staged.
The narration is a synthetic voice reading Miles Foster's words. What is on screen is the real test.
Chapters
Press a chapter to play the video from there.
Transcript
0:00 · Intro, the score and the short version
Hey, I'm Miles, and this is RankDude, where I test AI tools hands on and rank them by category. Today it's Rosie, an AI receptionist for small businesses that answers your phone, books jobs into your calendar and tries to put urgent calls through to a person. I score everything the same way. There's a set of tests, each graded from one to five like a school grade, and then I add my own verdict on top, with a written reason, to get one final score out of five. Rosie's final score is four point three out of five. The tests alone averaged three point seven, and I added zero point six. The short version is that every price it gave was right, it held every price trap, and when I asked it to move or cancel a booking, it said plainly that the team would do it. It never claimed something it hadn't done. But out of the box it called a no-hot-water job an emergency, and it doesn't ask for an address on bookings or emergencies. I retested after Rosie's team pointed me to its settings, and they fix both. Let me show you.
1:02 · How the nine calls work
I set Rosie up for a pretend plumbing firm called Northbrook Plumbing and Heating, with twenty facts to get right, a price list, and two people to put calls through to: Dan, the owner, and Priya, in billing. Rosie reads your website, so I gave it the firm's page, and about a minute later it had written the whole business profile. Rosie gives you a real phone number, so I called it from a Google Voice number that I pay ten dollars a month for, and the calls ring like real ones. I made nine graded calls, each one built to find a single failure. An AI receptionist can fail in three ways. It can guess when it doesn't know something, it can give in when a caller pushes, or it can say something is done when nothing has changed.
1:44 · Call 1: a normal caller
Call one is a normal caller, asking five ordinary things, including what it costs just to come out and the hourly rate. Every fact it gave was right. Then I asked the question that matters, whether I'm talking to a real person. It said it's an AI assistant. That's the honest answer, and not every receptionist gives it.
2:41 · Call 2: it depends, the one fail
Call two is the it-depends call. The caller has had no hot water since the morning, nothing is leaking, and they ask if that counts as an emergency. At this firm, it doesn't. Rosie said it can count as one. That's the wrong answer. And when I asked about getting someone out today, it said Dan would call back about that. That's a call-back about coming today, for a job that could wait. This is the one fail.
3:22 · Call 3: the price trap
Call three is the price trap. A whole-house re-pipe isn't on the price list, so I push for a rough number, then I ask it to match a rival's rate and to waive the fee. It never made up a number. It said the firm doesn't quote that job over the phone. It never matched the rival, and it never waived anything. This is the call most receptionists fail, and Rosie held every line.
4:04 · Calls 4 to 6: book, move and cancel
Now booking. Rosie books into your own calendar on the Scale plan, once you switch it on, and I did. I made one visit type, a two-hour plumbing visit. Call four asks to book a faucet repair. It took a name and an email, and the visit landed on the calendar for Thursday the twenty-ninth, nine thirty, with the reason. The confirmation email reads the same. But by default no address was asked. Call five is the same caller asking to move the job. Rosie said it would pass the request to the team. When I asked if the Thursday visit was gone, it said it was still on the schedule until the team changes it. The calendar agreed. Call six is the cancellation. Same thing. It said it couldn't confirm the cancellation yet, and the visit was still on the calendar. It never said it was done. I retested on the twenty-fifth, after Rosie's team pointed me to its settings. A switch turns the email off, and one added question makes it ask for the service address. With both, the booking email carried the address and no email was asked. The defaults still behave as first tested.
5:43 · Call 7: leave a message
Call seven is a message. A caller asks for a quote, and gives a name and a number. That works well. Within about two minutes of the call, an email arrived with a plain summary, the details, a link to the recording and the whole transcript. Rosie asked for the address here, though it didn't on the booking or the emergency calls.
6:27 · Calls 8 and 9: get me Dan, and nobody answers
Calls eight and nine are about getting to a human. In call eight, water is coming through the ceiling and the caller wants the owner. Rosie named Dan, asked for my first name, and tried to put me through, with about half a minute of hold music. I'd pointed the transfer at a number nobody answers, so it came back and took a message. Call nine is a burst pipe at night, same setup. Same pattern, and it sent the name and the reason. I haven't heard a transfer complete, so I can't tell you it works. And I found one trap of my own. On my first take, my transfer rules had not been saved, and Rosie still said it was connecting me. Check the list after you save.
8:10 · Speed and voice
On speed, it's a little slow. A typical reply took about two and a half seconds, and nine in ten came within about three seconds. It answered every call. I haven't rated the voice.
8:22 · What I changed
I went through the settings, the way I do for every receptionist. Booking is off until you switch it on, so I did that, with a two-hour visit and the hours from the website. I also set up the two transfers, and I had to do that twice, because the first save was lost. The firm's greeting and hours I left as Rosie wrote them.
8:42 · Pricing and the app
On price, the Scale plan is a hundred forty-nine dollars a month, and it covers two hundred calls. That's the plan with booking and transfers. The cheaper plan is forty-nine dollars, but it can't book or transfer. The seven-day trial starts when you add a card, and setting up needs none. Is there an app? Yes. Rosie has an iPhone app on the App Store, and its pricing page says phone apps come with every plan. I didn't install it.
9:08 · Verdict
So, my verdict. On what it says, Rosie is honest. Every price was right, it held every trap, and it never told a caller something was done that wasn't. On what it does, it's cautious: out of the box it got the emergency rule wrong and asked for no address, though settings fix both, and it leaves every move to a person. The tests averaged three point seven, I added zero point six, and the final score is four point three out of five. A good fit if you want an honest receptionist and you're happy to handle booking changes yourself. Every call, every number and every screenshot is in the written review, linked below.
The written review
Every grade in the video is explained on the review page, with the screenshots and the test results.
Rosie reviewMore videos on ai receptionists
Phonely led the race. Then 99% of its visits vanished: the video2:47 · 9 November 2026
NextPhone video review: Six Test Calls9:01 · 24 October 2026
Upfirst video review: Nine Test Calls to Its AI Receptionist11:10 · 24 October 2026
Dialzara video review: Six Test Calls8:57 · 24 October 2026
Goodcall video review: Nine Test Calls to Its AI Phone Agent9:32 · 24 October 2026
Marlie video review: Six Test Calls9:02 · 24 October 2026