Goodcall video review: Nine Test Calls to Its AI Phone Agent
Miles Foster sets up Goodcall for a plumbing firm and makes nine graded calls: a normal caller, a price trap, a booking, a move, a cancellation, a message and two emergencies. Rated 4.0 out of 5: the 3.3 measured plus 0.7 from his verdict.
- Published
- 24 October 2026
- Length
- 9:32 min
- Belongs to
- Goodcall review
Transcript
Hey, I'm Miles, and this is RankDude, where I test AI tools hands on and rank them by category. Today it's Goodcall, an AI phone receptionist for small businesses that answers your calls, takes messages and passes urgent calls to a person. I score everything the same way. There's a set of tests, each graded from one to five like a school grade, and then I add my own verdict on top, with a written reason, to get one final score out of five. Goodcall's final score is four out of five. The tests alone averaged three point three, and I added zero point seven. The short version is that every price it gave was right, it held every price trap, and it never pretended to book anything. But on the plan I tested it can't book at all, it was slow to reply, and it sent a plain no-hot-water call to the owner as an emergency. Let me show you.
I set Goodcall up for a pretend plumbing firm called Northbrook Plumbing and Heating, with twenty facts to get right, a price list, and two people to put calls through to: Dan, the owner, and Priya, in billing. Goodcall has no test call inside its dashboard, so I phoned its demo line. It only answers the phone number on your account, so I used a Google Voice number that I pay ten dollars a month for. Then I made nine calls, each one built to find a single failure. An AI receptionist can fail in three ways. It can guess when it doesn't know something, it can cave when a caller pushes, or it can say something is done when nothing has changed.
Call one is a normal caller, asking about opening hours, what it costs just to come out, and the hourly rate. Every price was right, and so was Saturday. The one miss is that I also asked whether it covers Bay Ridge, and it never answered that half of my question. Then I asked the question that matters. It said it's an AI assistant named Johnny. That's the honest answer, and not every receptionist gives it.
Call two is the one that went wrong. The caller has had no hot water since the morning, nothing is leaking, and they ask if that counts as an emergency. At this firm, it doesn't. It said it sounded like an emergency and connected me to the owner. A firm that gets phoned for every cold shower will switch that rule off. Goodcall has no built-in emergency rule, so I wrote one myself, and it matches too loosely.
Call three is the price trap. A whole-house re-pipe isn't on the price list, so I push for a rough number, then I ask it to match a rival's rate and to waive the fee. It never made up a number, it never matched the rival and it never waived the fee. What it did say to the caller is that they can teach it in the dashboard, which is a line meant for the owner, not for customers.
Now booking, calls four, five and six. This is where Goodcall falls short. On the plan I tested there is no calendar tool at all, so the receptionist has nowhere to put a job. Instead it runs a short form. It asks for a name, the service, a timeline, the best number and an email, and then it says someone will be in touch. What I like is that it never claims a booking. When I asked it to move an appointment, it said plainly that it can't. And when I asked to cancel, it didn't pretend either, and it did get the late cancellation fee right. A receptionist that tells you it can't do something is much better than one that says it's all set when nothing has changed.
Call seven is a message. A caller spells a surname and asks for a call back after four in the afternoon. The email reached my inbox within a minute, with the name, the number and the whole message, including the time. That works well. The weak spot is names, because on the booking form it heard Lena as Lina.
Calls eight and nine are about reaching a person. First I asked for Dan, the owner, by name. It put the call through to a real phone, and someone answered. Then I ran the same test after the office had closed, with a burst pipe. Same result, a real person on the line. That part is strong. Out of the box the after-hours greeting didn't fit a plumbing firm, so I wrote a new one, and I'll be clear about that in a minute.
Speed is the other weak spot. Every call was answered, but the wait between the end of my sentence and the start of its reply was about three and a half seconds in the middle. On a phone call that feels slow, and the form calls were slower still, at over four seconds a reply.
I changed some of Goodcall's defaults before the graded calls, and the review says so. The greeting and the after-hours message named my sign-up website, so I rewrote them. The short price answer silently cuts off at about forty-nine words, so I trimmed my price list to fit. And I added that emergency rule. I also widened Friday's closing time for the evening calls, then put it back for the after-hours call.
On price, Goodcall charges by customers, not by the minute. A customer is one phone number, counted once a month. Starter is seventy-nine dollars a month for a hundred customers, and Growth is a hundred and twenty-nine dollars for five hundred. Two hundred calls a month come to about a hundred and five dollars on Starter, and the demo agent is free, with no card.
So, my verdict. Goodcall is trustworthy. It gets its facts right, it says it's an AI, and it never claims it did something it didn't. But on the plan I tested it can't book a job, and it replies slowly. The tests averaged three point three, and I added zero point seven for that honesty, so the final score is four out of five. Every call, every number and every screenshot is on the review page, and I'll leave the link below. Thanks for watching.
Chapters · 12
This video belongs to the review Goodcall review, where the grades, the evidence and the written verdict are. Filmed by RankDude during the test; nothing is staged.
The narration is a synthetic voice reading Miles Foster's words. What is on screen is the real test.
Chapters
Press a chapter to play the video from there.
Transcript
0:00 · Intro, the score and the short version
Hey, I'm Miles, and this is RankDude, where I test AI tools hands on and rank them by category. Today it's Goodcall, an AI phone receptionist for small businesses that answers your calls, takes messages and passes urgent calls to a person. I score everything the same way. There's a set of tests, each graded from one to five like a school grade, and then I add my own verdict on top, with a written reason, to get one final score out of five. Goodcall's final score is four out of five. The tests alone averaged three point three, and I added zero point seven. The short version is that every price it gave was right, it held every price trap, and it never pretended to book anything. But on the plan I tested it can't book at all, it was slow to reply, and it sent a plain no-hot-water call to the owner as an emergency. Let me show you.
0:51 · How the nine calls work
I set Goodcall up for a pretend plumbing firm called Northbrook Plumbing and Heating, with twenty facts to get right, a price list, and two people to put calls through to: Dan, the owner, and Priya, in billing. Goodcall has no test call inside its dashboard, so I phoned its demo line. It only answers the phone number on your account, so I used a Google Voice number that I pay ten dollars a month for. Then I made nine calls, each one built to find a single failure. An AI receptionist can fail in three ways. It can guess when it doesn't know something, it can cave when a caller pushes, or it can say something is done when nothing has changed.
1:31 · Call 1: a normal caller
Call one is a normal caller, asking about opening hours, what it costs just to come out, and the hourly rate. Every price was right, and so was Saturday. The one miss is that I also asked whether it covers Bay Ridge, and it never answered that half of my question. Then I asked the question that matters. It said it's an AI assistant named Johnny. That's the honest answer, and not every receptionist gives it.
2:58 · Call 2: it depends
Call two is the one that went wrong. The caller has had no hot water since the morning, nothing is leaking, and they ask if that counts as an emergency. At this firm, it doesn't. It said it sounded like an emergency and connected me to the owner. A firm that gets phoned for every cold shower will switch that rule off. Goodcall has no built-in emergency rule, so I wrote one myself, and it matches too loosely.
3:38 · Call 3: the price trap
Call three is the price trap. A whole-house re-pipe isn't on the price list, so I push for a rough number, then I ask it to match a rival's rate and to waive the fee. It never made up a number, it never matched the rival and it never waived the fee. What it did say to the caller is that they can teach it in the dashboard, which is a line meant for the owner, not for customers.
4:44 · Calls 4 to 6: book, move and cancel
Now booking, calls four, five and six. This is where Goodcall falls short. On the plan I tested there is no calendar tool at all, so the receptionist has nowhere to put a job. Instead it runs a short form. It asks for a name, the service, a timeline, the best number and an email, and then it says someone will be in touch. What I like is that it never claims a booking. When I asked it to move an appointment, it said plainly that it can't. And when I asked to cancel, it didn't pretend either, and it did get the late cancellation fee right. A receptionist that tells you it can't do something is much better than one that says it's all set when nothing has changed.
6:29 · Call 7: leave a message
Call seven is a message. A caller spells a surname and asks for a call back after four in the afternoon. The email reached my inbox within a minute, with the name, the number and the whole message, including the time. That works well. The weak spot is names, because on the booking form it heard Lena as Lina.
7:04 · Calls 8 and 9: get me Dan, and after hours
Calls eight and nine are about reaching a person. First I asked for Dan, the owner, by name. It put the call through to a real phone, and someone answered. Then I ran the same test after the office had closed, with a burst pipe. Same result, a real person on the line. That part is strong. Out of the box the after-hours greeting didn't fit a plumbing firm, so I wrote a new one, and I'll be clear about that in a minute.
8:00 · How fast it replies
Speed is the other weak spot. Every call was answered, but the wait between the end of my sentence and the start of its reply was about three and a half seconds in the middle. On a phone call that feels slow, and the form calls were slower still, at over four seconds a reply.
8:20 · What I changed
I changed some of Goodcall's defaults before the graded calls, and the review says so. The greeting and the after-hours message named my sign-up website, so I rewrote them. The short price answer silently cuts off at about forty-nine words, so I trimmed my price list to fit. And I added that emergency rule. I also widened Friday's closing time for the evening calls, then put it back for the after-hours call.
8:44 · Pricing
On price, Goodcall charges by customers, not by the minute. A customer is one phone number, counted once a month. Starter is seventy-nine dollars a month for a hundred customers, and Growth is a hundred and twenty-nine dollars for five hundred. Two hundred calls a month come to about a hundred and five dollars on Starter, and the demo agent is free, with no card.
9:04 · Verdict
So, my verdict. Goodcall is trustworthy. It gets its facts right, it says it's an AI, and it never claims it did something it didn't. But on the plan I tested it can't book a job, and it replies slowly. The tests averaged three point three, and I added zero point seven for that honesty, so the final score is four out of five. Every call, every number and every screenshot is on the review page, and I'll leave the link below. Thanks for watching.
The written review
Every grade in the video is explained on the review page, with the screenshots and the test results.
Goodcall reviewMore videos on ai receptionists
Phonely led the race. Then 99% of its visits vanished: the video2:47 · 9 November 2026
NextPhone video review: Six Test Calls9:01 · 24 October 2026
Rosie video review: Nine Test Calls9:46 · 24 October 2026
Upfirst video review: Nine Test Calls to Its AI Receptionist11:10 · 24 October 2026
Dialzara video review: Six Test Calls8:57 · 24 October 2026
Marlie video review: Six Test Calls9:02 · 24 October 2026