Edit checklist
The same ten edits for every logo generator: typeface, hex colour, icon position, letter spacing, icon swap, icon shape, tagline, icon size, one-colour version and undo.
- When it runs
- After the first concepts, on the coffee roaster logo
- Used in
- 2 reviews
- Runs on
- The browser the test runs in
What the edit checklist is
A logo you cannot adjust is a template. The checklist asks the editor for ten changes a real owner would want and counts each only when it was done without a workaround such as redrawing the logo elsewhere.
I drive the editor with the same steps every time and record the screen while I do it, so the footage shows each edit being made and, for the last one, undone.
How it works
- I open the chosen logo in the editor and note the starting state with a screenshot.
- I make the ten edits in the fixed order. A colour edit uses a typed hex code, not a swatch.
- After each edit I capture the result. An edit counts when it did what the checklist asks without a workaround.
- The last edit is undo back to the starting logo, which tests whether the history reaches all the way.
What it records
- Per edit
- Done or not done, the control used and a screenshot of the result.
- Per review
- How many of the ten were done, which sets the editing grade.
What it cannot catch
- The steps are driven by coordinates on the editor's screen, so an editor redesign means the script is rewritten.
- Whether an edit looks good is not graded here, only whether the control did what was asked.
Where it was used
Every published review that ran this checker, with the figure it produced there, read from the review’s own data. Each figure opens the test results behind it.
| Review | Figure | Tested |
|---|---|---|
| 9 of 10 edits that worked | Invalid Date | |
| 9 / 10 edits done | Invalid Date |
Review
- Tested
- Invalid Date
- Figure
- 9 / 10 edits done
- Tested
- Invalid Date
The other checkers for ai logo generator
- Concept sheet
- Small-size renderer
- Terms reader
- Brief set
- Small-size render
- File inspector
- Timed run
- Brief set
- File inspector
- AI logo generator methodology
- All checkers
Written by Miles Foster, Owner and tester, RankDude. How RankDude tests and grades is on the methodology page.