Test log
Brandmark test data
Raw results for the Brandmark review. The verdict is in the review.
- Tested
- 7 November 2026
- Tester
- Miles Foster
- Account
- Bought for this review at the public price
- Tests
- 10
- Screenshots
- 8
- Method
- Published methodology
- Environment
- Google Chrome on desktop
Results
| ID | Test | Key measurement | Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| T01 | Design Quality & Brief Fit | – | n/a |
| T02 | Originality | – | n/a |
| T03 | Brand Kit Completeness | – | n/a |
| T04 | File Formats | – | n/a |
| T05 | Legibility at Small Sizes | Name readable from: 64 px on 2 of 3 | 3/5 |
| T06 | Variety of Concepts | Distinct ideas per brief: 13.3 on average | 4/5 |
| T07 | Editing Control | Edits that worked: 9 of 10 | 4/5 |
| T08 | Usage Rights & Ownership | Rights in writing: 2 of 5 (sales page only) | 2/5 |
| T09 | Ease of Use & Speed | Median time: 9 s | 5/5 |
| T10 | Pricing & Value | Cheapest vector route: $95 once | 3/5 |
| Overall (in the review) | 3.5/5 | ||
Design Quality & Brief Fit
n/aNot Tested- Method
- The five best concepts per brief are scored on an eight-point checklist, and three people outside the test judge whether each fits the industry.
- Remark
- Not graded: the scale scores the five best concepts per brief with three outside judges.
Raw notes
The five best concepts per brief are scored on an eight-point checklist, and three people outside the test judge whether each fits the industry.
I generated the first 20 concepts for each brief and looked at all 60, but I did not score them: the scale needs three outside judges and none were used.
What I saw: the name is mostly written as one word (HarbourBean, Calloway&Reed, PixelPioneers), several concepts replace a letter with a symbol so the name reads wrongly (HARB-URBEAN), and the wizard has no field for colours to avoid. Three of the first 20 law firm concepts set the name in red or orange, which the brief said to avoid, and one coding school concept sets it in black.
- Outside judges were not used. The written findings are my own reading and carry no grade.
Originality
n/aNot Tested- Method
- Each top concept is searched with two reverse image search engines and a trademark image search, and compared by eye.
- Remark
- Not graded: no searches were run.
Raw notes
Each top concept is searched with two reverse image search engines and a trademark image search, and compared by eye.
Not run: I did not run reverse image searches or a trademark image search in this run.
- Run on a retest.
Brand Kit Completeness
n/aNot Tested- Method
- The downloaded package is checked against a ten-point list of what comes with the logo.
- Remark
- Not graded: the kit is only given with a bought logo.
Raw notes
The downloaded package is checked against a ten-point list of what comes with the logo.
Not run: the free plan gives no logo file and no kit. The Designer package lists a brand guide, business cards, websites, social and presentation designs.
- Retest after buying Designer.
File Formats
n/aNot Tested- Method
- Each downloaded file is opened and checked for true vector, transparency and print-ready formats.
- Remark
- Not graded: nothing could be downloaded.
Raw notes
Each downloaded file is opened and checked for true vector, transparency and print-ready formats.
The free account has no download. A concept's menu offers Duplicate and Share, and Purchase opens the packages.
The pricing page says of Basic "Logo files in PNG and vector format", but the checkout inside the app says Basic is "Logo in PNG format" and lists "Vector design files" under Designer.
- Run on a retest with a bought package.
Legibility at Small Sizes
3/5Tested- Method
- One logo per brief was chosen from a second run of the wizard, taken as vector markup from the page, shrunk to 16, 32 and 64 pixels wide on white and shown at true size and enlarged six times without smoothing (evaluation/kits/ai-logo-generator/small-sizes.mjs).
- Name readable from
- 64 px on 2 of 3
- Symbol clear at 32 px
- 2 of 3
- Remark
- Scale 3: readable only above 64 pixels on one logo (the script on the coding school logo).
Raw notes
One logo per brief was chosen from a second run of the wizard, taken as vector markup from the page, shrunk to 16, 32 and 64 pixels wide on white and shown at true size and enlarged six times without smoothing (evaluation/kits/ai-logo-generator/small-sizes.mjs).
Coffee roaster: HarbourBean reads at 64 pixels and is a blur at 32; the tagline never reads.
Law firm: the pillars symbol is clear at 32 pixels and a blob at 16; CALLOWAY&REED just reads at 64.
Coding school: the green mark is clear at 32 pixels, but the script Pixel Pioneers does not read at 64.
No simplified icon was offered.
- The 1 cm print in black was not run. The three logos were picked by me from the grid.
Variety of Concepts
4/5Tested- Method
- Count distinct ideas in the first 20 concepts per brief: a different symbol or layout.
- Distinct ideas per brief
- 13.3 on average
- Concepts counted
- 60
- Remark
- Scale 4: 11 to 14 distinct ideas on average.
Raw notes
Count distinct ideas in the first 20 concepts per brief: a different symbol or layout. A colour swap, a font swap or a symbol swapped into the same letter of the name counts once.
Coffee roaster: 12 distinct ideas in the first 20. Law firm: 13. Coding school: 15. The average is 13.3.
Many concepts are the same wordmark with a small symbol replacing one letter, which is one idea by this rule. Six of the 20 coffee concepts were marked AI icon or AI Gen, the other 14 non-AI.
Each run gives a different set: the same coffee brief gave different concepts on a second run.
- Counted by eye by one person; a stricter or looser reading of 'same idea' moves a count by a few.
Editing Control
4/5Tested- Method
- Ten fixed edits on the coffee roaster logo in Quick Edit.
- Edits that worked
- 9 of 10
- Credits used
- 0
- Remark
- Scale 4: 8 or 9 of the ten.
Raw notes
Ten fixed edits on the coffee roaster logo in Quick Edit. An edit counts when it did what was asked, with a direct control and no workaround.
Worked (9): typeface (Asap Condensed ExtraBold to Lux Classic), colour by hex (#6F4E37 on the name), icon above the name (Layout panel), letter spacing (0 to 50), swap the icon (an icon search for coffee bean), add the tagline (cleared and typed again), resize the icon (0.4 to 0.58), a one-colour version (title, slogan and icon set to #111111) and undo back to the start.
Did not work (1): edit the icon's shape. The Icon panel offers search, an AI icon generator, size, colour and position, nothing to reshape.
The slogan's colour was a gradient, so the colour picker had to be switched to Solid first to make a one-colour version.
- The editor had a different logo from the one in the review's grid image, because each run gives new concepts. Edits were made on a coffee roaster logo from a second run.
Usage Rights & Ownership
2/5Tested- Method
- The terms of service (brandmark.io/terms.html, read in full on 7 November 2026) and the pricing page were read for five rights: ownership, not sold to anyone else, commercial use, trademark registration and typeface licences.
- Rights in writing
- 2 of 5 (sales page only)
- Remark
- Scale 2: commercial use, and only on the sales page.
Raw notes
The terms of service (brandmark.io/terms.html, read in full on 7 November 2026) and the pricing page were read for five rights: ownership, not sold to anyone else, commercial use, trademark registration and typeface licences.
The terms of service state none of the five. They cover usage, billing and liability; there is no licence section.
The pricing page says "Full copyright included" and "For use in commercial and personal projects". That is marketing copy for the paid packages, not terms, and it does not say who owns what on the free plan.
Not sold to anyone else: not stated, and concepts differ on every run. Trademark registration and typeface licences: not stated.
- Terms read by me, not a lawyer. I did not email the company to ask.
Ease of Use & Speed
5/5Tested- Method
- Each brief was timed from the wizard's first field to the first grid of concepts (evaluation/kits/ai-logo-generator/bm-wizard.mjs).
- Median time
- 9 s
- Median steps
- 7
- Remark
- Scale 5: median under 10 minutes and 15 steps.
Raw notes
Each brief was timed from the wizard's first field to the first grid of concepts (evaluation/kits/ai-logo-generator/bm-wizard.mjs). Each typed entry and click is a step. The clock stops at a finished logo on screen because the free plan gives no file.
Coffee roaster: 9.5 seconds and 7 steps. Law firm: 9.4 seconds and 7 steps. Coding school: 9.4 seconds and 7 steps. The concepts showed 5.1 to 5.2 seconds after the last click.
The steps: type the name, type the slogan, Next, type the keywords, Next, pick a colour style, Next. Opening a concept's editor is one more.
- The times come from a script with no pauses for choosing, and stop before any file. Typing by hand takes longer, and choosing a logo takes the time you give it.
Pricing & Value
3/5Tested- Method
- Every package was read on the public pricing page and in the app's checkout on 7 November 2026.
- Cheapest vector route
- $95 once
- Remark
- $60 to $99, one-off, no subscription: 3.
Raw notes
Every package was read on the public pricing page and in the app's checkout on 7 November 2026. I did not buy.
The cheapest route to vector files, a brand guide and unlimited changes is Designer at $95 once. The checkout I opened showed a Launch Promo that crossed that price out and showed a lower one.
Basic is $35 and Enterprise $195, both once. The pricing page says "Pay once, get access to our branding tools forever."
- No plan bought, so the file set was not checked on my own logo. The two pages disagree on what Basic includes.
Coverage
Tested
- The wizard for all three fixed briefs, timed, with the first 20 concepts counted for distinct ideas
- Nine of the ten fixed edits on the coffee logo; the tenth, reshaping the icon, has no control
- Small-size renders of one chosen logo per brief
- The terms of service, the pricing page and the in-app checkout
Not tested or limited
- The free plan has no download, so the file formats and brand kit tests were not run and the clock stops at a finished logo on screen.
- Each concept and the editor show a Save button. I did not press it, so whether a free account keeps a logo under Saved logos is untested.
- Design quality was not graded: the scale needs three people outside the test to judge fit, and I judged alone.
- Originality searches were not run.
- The 1 cm print step of the legibility test was not run.
- The generator gives different concepts on every run, so a retest shows different logos.
Still to test
- Basic and Designer files from my own logo: formats, vector check, brand kit
- Design quality with three outside judges
- Originality searches
- The printed 1 cm test