Concept sheet
Variety is counted from a picture of the concepts, not from memory. The concept sheet puts the first 20 results for one brief on a single numbered page.
- When it runs
- After each brief's first results
- Used in
- 2 reviews
- Runs on
- My PC, from the pages the generator showed
What the concept sheet is
A generator can show a grid of logos that look different at a glance and are the same symbol in twenty colours. To count honestly I need all twenty in one view, in the order the tool showed them, with a number on each so every count can be checked.
The sheet only arranges the images. Deciding what counts as a different idea is my call on the published rule: a different symbol, layout or type treatment is one idea; a colour swap, a font swap or the same icon moved counts once.
How it works
- Each concept card on the results page is captured as its own image at twice the screen resolution, in the order shown.
- The first 20 images of a brief are scaled to the same cell size and placed on one page in five columns, each labelled with its number.
- I count the distinct ideas on the sheet by eye and write the groups, with the numbers in each, into a note kept with the evidence.
What it records
- Per brief
- The contact sheet image and a note listing each idea with the concept numbers behind it.
- Per review
- The average number of distinct ideas across the three briefs, which sets the variety grade.
What it cannot catch
- The count is a judgement by eye. The numbered groups are kept so a reader can disagree with a single call.
- Only what the tool shows without payment is captured. A tool that hides concepts behind a plan shows fewer of them.
Where it was used
Every published review that ran this checker, with the figure it produced there, read from the review’s own data. Each figure opens the test results behind it.
| Review | Figure | Tested |
|---|---|---|
| 13.3 distinct ideas per brief | Invalid Date | |
| 14.3 ideas per brief | Invalid Date |
Review
- Tested
- Invalid Date
- Figure
- 14.3 ideas per brief
- Tested
- Invalid Date
The other checkers for ai logo generator
- Edit checklist
- Small-size renderer
- Terms reader
- Brief set
- Small-size render
- File inspector
- Timed run
- Brief set
- File inspector
- AI logo generator methodology
- All checkers
Written by Miles Foster, Owner and tester, RankDude. How RankDude tests and grades is on the methodology page.