Test log
Storydoc test data
Raw results for the Storydoc review. The verdict is in the review.
- Tested
- 6 November 2026
- Tester
- Miles Foster
- Account
- Free demo account, signed up by RankDude, nothing paid to the brand
- Tests
- 10
- Screenshots
- 8
- Method
- Published methodology
- Environment
- Google Chrome on desktop
Results
| ID | Test | Key measurement | Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| T01 | Export Fidelity | – | n/a |
| T02 | Structure from a Prompt | Structure points: 21 of 21 | 5/5 |
| T03 | Slide Design | Layout faults: 12 | 3/5 |
| T04 | Content Accuracy | Brief figures right: All | 2/5 |
| T05 | Use of a Supplied Document | Points covered: 12 of 15 | 2/5 |
| T06 | Editing Control | Edits that worked: 9 of 12 | 3/5 |
| T07 | Brand & Theme Control | Slides with the right logo: 0 of 32 | 2/5 |
| T08 | Charts & Images | Charts correct: 1 of 3 | 2/5 |
| T09 | Speed | Median, outline to deck: 36 seconds | 5/5 |
| T10 | Pricing & Value | – | 3/5 |
| Overall (in the review) | 3.8/5 | ||
Export Fidelity
n/aNot Tested- Method
- Export each deck to PowerPoint, Google Slides and PDF and compare slide by slide.
- Remark
- Not graded; left out of the average.
Raw notes
Export each deck to PowerPoint, Google Slides and PDF and compare slide by slide.
Not run: the download icon offers Export PDF only. It says it will set the document live, and then asks you to activate the account by email. I found no PowerPoint or Google Slides export in the menus.
- No .pptx file exists to open in PowerPoint; the PDF was not made.
Structure from a Prompt
5/5Tested- Method
- Each first draft was checked for seven points: the slide count within one of the request, a title slide, an agenda or opening, a logical order, one idea per slide, a conclusion or clear ask, and no repeated slides.
- Structure points
- 21 of 21
- Slides in the three decks
- 10, 12 and 10
- Remark
- Scale 5: 20 or 21 of 21 points.
Raw notes
Each first draft was checked for seven points: the slide count within one of the request, a title slide, an agenda or opening, a logical order, one idea per slide, a conclusion or clear ask, and no repeated slides. Three decks give 21 points.
All 21 points were met. The quarterly review had ten slides, the water cycle deck twelve and the pitch deck ten, each with a title slide, an opening, a logical order and a closing slide with a call to action.
Storydoc has no slide count box: you choose a length of brief, moderate or detailed. The outline still came back with the number of slides I asked for in the prompt, every time.
- The points were checked by eye by one person.
Slide Design
3/5Tested- Method
- All 32 slides of the three first drafts were captured at 2x and checked for the seven faults: text overflow, overlap, contrast, misalignment, mixed fonts, walls of text over 60 words, and blurry or unrelated images.
- Layout faults
- 12
- Slides checked
- 32
- Faults per ten slides
- 3.8
- Remark
- Scale 3: 3 to 4.9 faults per 10 slides.
Raw notes
All 32 slides of the three first drafts were captured at 2x and checked for the seven faults: text overflow, overlap, contrast, misalignment, mixed fonts, walls of text over 60 words, and blurry or unrelated images. Faults were counted per ten slides.
I counted 12 faults in 32 slides, 3.8 per ten slides. Each deck used a stock portrait of an unrelated person on its letter slide and its closing slide (six). A placeholder logo reading "Logoipsum" sat on two title slides (two). The pitch deck's team slide showed two grey avatar icons instead of photos (one). The water cycle agenda had faint stage names behind its text (one), a rain slide showed a forest with no rain (one), and the risks slide of the quarterly review held about 110 words (one).
Every draft also leaves the fields {{first_name}} and {{sender_name}} showing, and ends on a fake address, phone number and email ("9876 Oak Lane", "yourmail@example.com"). I did not count those.
- Faults were counted by eye at one window size, 1,366 by 860. Text contrast was not measured.
Content Accuracy
2/5Tested- Method
- Every figure in the quarterly review was compared with my table after the counting animation had finished, and every claim in the water cycle deck was read against the USGS Water Science School page.
- Brief figures right
- All
- Invented figures
- 1
- Errors in the water cycle deck
- 1
- Remark
- Scale 2: four to six errors, or any invented figure.
Raw notes
Every figure in the quarterly review was compared with my table after the counting animation had finished, and every claim in the water cycle deck was read against the USGS Water Science School page.
Every figure from my table was right: revenue of $1,368k against $1,214k and +12.7 per cent, the 41 per cent margin, satisfaction of 4.6, 10,540 orders, 1,797 new customers, 584 tickets, the three months and the four regions. Two figures Storydoc worked out itself, a fall of $31,000 and 12 per cent in the West, are right from my numbers.
One figure was invented. The KPI slide says revenue "exceeded the quarterly target of $1.3M"; I gave no target.
The water cycle deck says "97% of our planet's water eventually finds its way back to the massive oceans". The USGS page says oceans store 96% of Earth's water, so I counted one minor error.
- The water cycle deck was checked against the USGS page only. The pitch deck's invented details are counted under the supplied document test.
Use of a Supplied Document
2/5Tested- Method
- The pitch deck was made from the six-page seed memo, attached as a PDF.
- Points covered
- 12 of 15
- Incomplete
- 3
- Invented details
- 1
- Remark
- Scale 2: 4 to 7, or anything invented.
Raw notes
The pitch deck was made from the six-page seed memo, attached as a PDF. The 15 key points were listed before the test, and each was marked present, distorted or missing. Anything in the deck that is not in the memo was counted as invented.
12 of 15 points were covered correctly: the founders and their roles, the $1.5 million round, the 90 days, the 20 kg minimum, shipping within 48 hours, cafes from 2 kg with no contract, the market size and growth, 3,100 subscribers and 40 cafes, churn, revenue and margin, the 71 and 29 split, and lifetime value and the cost to win.
Three were incomplete: the founding year, 2023, is missing; the subscription rhythm of every two weeks or monthly is missing; and the use of funds names a second roaster, marketing and hiring without the 40, 35 and 25 per cent split.
Storydoc also added one thing the memo does not say: funds used to "double production output and expand our industrial footprint". The memo names a second roaster at 40 per cent and nothing about output, so I counted it as invented.
- The grade rests on the one invented detail. With 12 points covered and nothing invented it would be a 4.
Editing Control
3/5Tested- Method
- Twelve fixed edits on the quarterly review deck.
- Edits that worked
- 9 of 12
- Tokens per AI text action
- 1
- Tokens used in the whole test
- 1 of 25
- Remark
- Scale 3: 7 to 9.
Raw notes
Twelve fixed edits on the quarterly review deck. An edit counts when it did what was asked with a normal control and no workaround.
Nine of twelve worked: slides reordered by dragging their numbers on the rail, one slide's layout and height changed, a paragraph shortened by the AI, a blank slide inserted between two others, a chart's data edited in a spreadsheet with a second column added, an image replaced from the stock library, the colours and font changed for the whole deck in one place, three undo steps, and a comment left on the title.
Three did not: I could not regenerate a single slide (the slide menu offers translate, fix spelling, expand, shorten, formal and casual only), I found no speaker notes, and objects do not move freely: dragging the title did nothing, because text and images sit in fixed layout blocks.
Each AI text action cost 1 of the 25 tokens. Shortening the 110-word risks paragraph took about six seconds and kept "$31,000" and "12%".
- Show or hide slide and Make repeatable are marked as paid in the slide menu; I did not count them.
Brand & Theme Control
2/5Tested- Method
- I added the logo, the two hex colours and the font, and looked for a .pptx template import.
- Slides with the right logo
- 0 of 32
- Template import
- Not offered
- Colours applied in one step
- Yes
- Remark
- Scale 2: six or more slides off-brand.
Raw notes
I added the logo, the two hex colours and the font, and looked for a .pptx template import. Every slide was then checked for the right logo, exact colours and font; a slide with any of them wrong counts as off-brand.
The two colours, #0B3C5D and #F2A900, went in as base colours, and the font was already Montserrat. One click on Save changes recoloured the charts, numbers and lines of the whole quarterly review. The gold sits unused in the palette: no slide showed it.
The logo could not be placed. The header logo is marked as paid, and Design settings offer a brand import by name or website, not a logo upload. No .pptx template import was offered. So none of the 32 slides carried the right logo, and the other two decks were never branded.
- The brand colours were applied to the quarterly review only. A logo may be possible by adding it as a picture on each slide; I counted that as a workaround.
Charts & Images
2/5Tested- Method
- The quarterly review asked for a bar chart of revenue by region, Q2 against Q3, a line chart of monthly revenue and a KPI panel.
- Charts correct
- 1 of 3
- Native charts with a data sheet
- 2 of 2
- Remark
- Scale 2: two or more charts wrong, or images with no licence.
Raw notes
The quarterly review asked for a bar chart of revenue by region, Q2 against Q3, a line chart of monthly revenue and a KPI panel. Each value was checked, and each chart was tested for whether it stays an editable chart. Every image was checked for relevance and source.
Two of the three charts were wrong. The regional bar chart showed Q3 only, four bars with no Q2, and the monthly revenue came as a bar chart, not a line. The KPI panel was right: $1,368K, +12.7% and 41%.
Both charts are native: Edit data opens a spreadsheet, and I fixed the bar chart by typing in the Q2 figures. I did not try the Chart type switch.
The photos suit their slides, apart from the faults counted under design. The title photo of a bike carries another maker's name, "VELOCITI". The media library names the photographer of a stock photo, but the slide shows no source.
- The line chart was never produced, so the Chart type switch is untested.
Speed
5/5Tested- Method
- Each brief was sent as soon as it was typed.
- Median, outline to deck
- 36 seconds
- Fastest and slowest
- 30 and 42 seconds
- Tokens used by the three decks
- 0
- Remark
- Scale 5: median under 1 minute.
Raw notes
Each brief was sent as soon as it was typed. The clock ran from confirming the outline to the last slide finished and editable. The outline step was timed too.
The decks were finished 36 seconds (quarterly review), 30 seconds (water cycle) and 42 seconds (pitch deck) after I confirmed the outline. The median is 36 seconds. The outlines took 24, 21 and 21 seconds.
None of the three decks used any of the 25 AI tokens.
- Three runs on one day; the times depend on load.
Pricing & Value
3/5Tested- Method
- Plans were read in the upgrade page inside the editor, in the monthly and annual views, and on the public pricing page.
- Remark
- Scale 3: $15 to $24.99 a month for the cheapest plan that exports a file without branding.
Raw notes
Plans were read in the upgrade page inside the editor, in the monthly and annual views, and on the public pricing page.
The cheapest paid plan, Starter, is $33 a month, or $19.80 a month paid yearly on the public page. It removes Storydoc branding and exports PDF, with 5 active documents and 25 AI text and 20 AI image credits a month. Pro is $60 a month, or $36 paid yearly, with 30 documents.
The upgrade page inside the editor showed a yearly early-bird discount of 60 per cent with a countdown of about 46 hours, so it showed lower yearly prices than the public page: Starter at $13.20 a month billed yearly ($158.40) and Pro at $24 ($288). The grade uses the public standing price of $19.80 a month, because the checkout price carried a countdown. The plan table lists Export to PDF and no PowerPoint export at all, so the plan I graded is Starter for a PDF without branding.
- No plan was bought, so I did not see a paid PDF.
Other features checked
Coverage
Tested
- Three fixed briefs, one of them with a six-page PDF attached, each outline confirmed and each deck timed
- Seven structure points on each deck, every slide checked for layout faults, every figure against the brief and the pitch deck against 15 key points
- Twelve fixed edits on the quarterly review deck, the brand colours and font in Design settings, the Download menu, the plans, the Terms and the Trustpilot profile
Not tested or limited
- Export fidelity was not graded: the download icon offers only Export PDF, it asks you to activate the account by email before it starts, and I found no PowerPoint or Google Slides export
- A .pptx template could not be imported: Design settings offer a brand import by name or website, colours, fonts and media, but no template upload
- The water cycle deck was checked against the USGS Water Science School page only, not the NASA page
- Text contrast was read by eye, not measured with a checker
- Slides are sections of a scrolling page. Figures count up as you scroll, so every figure was read after the count had finished
- Brand colours were applied to the quarterly review only. No plan was bought, so a paid PDF was not seen
Still to test
- Export fidelity once a PDF export can be made, and any PowerPoint route on a paid plan
- Logo and template import on a paid month
- The line chart through the Chart type switch
- Real-time collaboration with a second account