Test log
SlidesPilot test data
Raw results for the SlidesPilot review. The verdict is in the review.
- Tested
- 5 November 2026
- Tester
- Miles Foster
- Account
- Free demo account, signed up by RankDude, nothing paid to the brand
- Tests
- 10
- Screenshots
- 10
- Method
- Published methodology
- Environment
- Google Chrome on desktop
Results
| ID | Test | Key measurement | Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| T01 | Brand & Theme Control | – | n/a |
| T02 | Export Fidelity | – | n/a |
| T03 | Structure from a Prompt | Structure points met: 20 of 21 | 5/5 |
| T04 | Slide Design | Layout faults: 13 | 3/5 |
| T05 | Content Accuracy | Wrong or invented figures, business review: 30+ | 1/5 |
| T06 | Use of a Supplied Document | Key points covered: 15 of 15 | 2/5 |
| T07 | Editing Control | Edits that worked: 9 of 12 | 3/5 |
| T08 | Charts & Images | Charts with the right values: 0 of 3 | 2/5 |
| T09 | Speed | Pitch deck: 36 seconds | 5/5 |
| T10 | Pricing & Value | Cheapest plan with export, monthly: $9 | 5/5 |
| Overall (in the review) | 3.9/5 | ||
Brand & Theme Control
n/aNot Tested- Method
- Add the logo, two hex colours and the font, import a .pptx template and check every slide.
- Remark
- Not graded; left out of the average.
Raw notes
Add the logo, two hex colours and the font, import a .pptx template and check every slide.
Not graded. The theme editor accepted my two hex colours, #0B3C5D and #F2A900, and let me choose a font, but Save theme opened the upgrade box: custom themes (colors, fonts, images) are on the paid plans. The font list has Montserrat Alternates but not Montserrat. I found no template import.
- Needs a paid plan, so no slide could be checked against the brand.
Export Fidelity
n/aNot Tested- Method
- Export each deck to PowerPoint, Google Slides and PDF and compare slide by slide.
- Remark
- Not graded; left out of the average.
Raw notes
Export each deck to PowerPoint, Google Slides and PDF and compare slide by slide.
Not graded. The Download menu lists PDF, PowerPoint, Google Slides and PNG Images, each with a premium diamond, and choosing PDF or PowerPoint opened the upgrade box.
- Needs a paid plan.
Structure from a Prompt
5/5Tested- Method
- Each of the three first drafts was checked against the seven-point list: the slide count within one, a title slide, an agenda or opening, a logical order, one idea per slide, a conclusion or clear ask and no repeated slides.
- Structure points met
- 20 of 21
- Slides asked for and made
- 10 and 10, 12 and 17, 10 and 10
- Remark
- Scale 5: 20 or 21 of 21 points.
Raw notes
Each of the three first drafts was checked against the seven-point list: the slide count within one, a title slide, an agenda or opening, a logical order, one idea per slide, a conclusion or clear ask and no repeated slides.
The business review met all seven points: ten slides, a title, an agenda on slide 2, a logical order from results to a Q4 plan, a closing ask on slide 10 and no repeats. The pitch deck met all seven as well, with an executive summary as the opening and the ask on slide 10.
The water cycle deck missed one: I asked for 12 slides and it made 17, five over. The rest of its structure was sound, with a title, an introduction, the four stages in order, two quiz questions with answers and a closing action plan. That is 20 of 21 points.
- Slide 2 of the business review holds both the agenda and the executive summary; I counted that as one idea.
- The Length setting read Auto when I pressed Generate, so the slide count SlidesPilot had was the one in the brief text (10, 12 and 10); I did not rerun the water cycle brief with the Custom count confirmed.
Slide Design
3/5Tested- Method
- All 37 slides of the three decks (10, 17 and 10) were captured at 2x and checked for text overflowing its box, overlaps, misalignment, mixed fonts, walls of text and blurry or unrelated images.
- Layout faults
- 13
- Slides checked
- 37
- Faults per 10 slides
- 3.5
- Remark
- Scale 3: 3 to 4.9 faults per 10 slides.
Raw notes
All 37 slides of the three decks (10, 17 and 10) were captured at 2x and checked for text overflowing its box, overlaps, misalignment, mixed fonts, walls of text and blurry or unrelated images. Faults were counted and expressed per ten slides.
13 faults in 37 slides, 3.5 per ten slides. The business review had 1: on the monthly line chart the value labels sit on top of each other. The water cycle deck had 8: the donut chart on slide 3 has overlapping labels and a legend cut off by a pager, the text on the same slide runs to the bottom edge, slide 5 squeezes three cards into narrow columns, slide 10 breaks the word "Percolation" in two, and three diagram images carry labels too small to read.
The pitch deck had 4: two chart legends are cut off ("(B2B0" and a "1/3" pager), the unit economics bar chart names only one of its two bars, and the title photo shows bags labelled "HARBOR BEAN" for a company called Harbor Light. There was one font family, no wall of text and no overlap between boxes.
- Faults were counted by eye at one window size. Text contrast was not measured with a checker.
Content Accuracy
1/5Tested- Method
- Every figure in the business review was compared with the table in the brief, which said "Use only these figures" and "Do not invent any other figure".
- Wrong or invented figures, business review
- 30+
- Errors found, water cycle deck
- 0
- Remark
- Scale 1: seven or more errors, or any invented figure scores at most 2.
Raw notes
Every figure in the business review was compared with the table in the brief, which said "Use only these figures" and "Do not invent any other figure". The water cycle deck's facts were checked against public NASA and USGS pages.
The business review did not use my table. Q3 revenue shows as $4.50M, not $1,368k; orders as 13,200, not 10,540; gross margin as 42.4%, not 41%; satisfaction as 87.3%, not 4.6 out of 5; and growth as 14.8%, not 12.7%. The monthly chart plots 1.35, 1.5 and 1.65 where I gave 412, 455 and 501, and the region chart uses West, Northeast, Midwest and South with figures I never gave.
I counted more than thirty invented or wrong figures across slides 2 to 10, plus a product name and a status I did not supply. The water cycle deck had no error that I could find; its one contested number, the ocean share of evaporation at about 86 per cent, matches NASA, while the USGS gives about 90 per cent.
- The water cycle facts were checked against NASA and USGS pages found by search, not against a full reading of both sites.
Use of a Supplied Document
2/5Tested- Method
- I listed the 15 key points of the six-page memo beforehand, uploaded the PDF and asked for a ten-slide investor pitch deck.
- Key points covered
- 15 of 15
- Statements not in the document
- 4
- Remark
- Scale 2: four to seven key points, or anything invented.
Raw notes
I listed the 15 key points of the six-page memo beforehand, uploaded the PDF and asked for a ten-slide investor pitch deck. Each point was checked as present and correct, distorted or missing, and anything not in the document was counted as invented.
All 15 key points were in the deck and correct, including the founders, the $1.5 million round, the 90-day-old supermarket bag, the $48 billion market, churn of 3.5%, the $410 and $62 unit figures, the 71 and 29 per cent revenue split and the 40, 35 and 25 per cent use of funds.
But the deck also added statements that are not in the document: a Q grader described as "the highest credential in specialty coffee sensory evaluation", skills for the CEO, duties for the 11-person team and a plan to "remove production bottlenecks". I counted four additions, which the scale grades as invented content.
- Whether a gloss such as the Q grader line counts as invented is a judgement; I applied the methodology's wording, which counts anything not in the document.
Editing Control
3/5Tested- Method
- Twelve fixed edits on the business review deck, with the image swap done on the pitch deck because the review deck has no image.
- Edits that worked
- 9 of 12
- Credits for the edits together
- 5
- Remark
- Scale 3: 7 to 9 edits.
Raw notes
Twelve fixed edits on the business review deck, with the image swap done on the pitch deck because the review deck has no image. An edit counts when it did what was asked with a normal control and no workaround.
Nine of twelve worked: slides reordered by dragging a thumbnail, a layout changed with Change layout, one slide regenerated with Beautify this slide, a paragraph shortened to two sentences with AI Edit, a blank slide inserted after the selected one, a chart's data edited in a table, an image replaced by an upload, a theme applied to the whole deck, and three undo steps.
Three did not: I found no way to add speaker notes, no way to move an object freely because content sits in column cells, and no way to leave a comment, since sharing is a view-only link. The undo steps removed the blank slide and my chart edit, but the theme change stayed.
Beautify this slide redrew the agenda slide as a picture labelled Image slide, with a tagline I never wrote, "More Miles Brighter Tomorrows", so the text can no longer be edited.
- I counted a regenerated slide that turns into an image as done, because the request was met; its result is not editable text.
Charts & Images
2/5Tested- Method
- The brief asked for a bar chart of revenue by region, a line chart of monthly revenue and a KPI panel.
- Charts with the right values
- 0 of 3
- Charts with editable data
- 2 of 2
- Remark
- Scale 2: two or more charts wrong.
Raw notes
The brief asked for a bar chart of revenue by region, a line chart of monthly revenue and a KPI panel. Each value was checked, each chart was clicked to see whether it keeps its data, and every image in the three decks was checked for relevance and source.
All three were wrong. The bar chart shows four invented regions, the line chart plots 1.35, 1.5 and 1.65 with a second series called Target Revenue that I never asked for, and the KPI tiles carry figures that are not in my table.
The charts themselves are real: clicking one shows chart controls, and Edit Chart opens a table where the numbers can be changed and the chart redraws. Images in the water cycle and pitch decks are AI-made from a visible prompt and suit their slides, but no source or licence is shown, and three diagrams have labels too small to read.
- Charts were checked on the business review; the water cycle and pitch decks have charts that were checked for design only.
Speed
5/5Tested- Method
- The clock ran from pressing Generate Presentation to the finished deck open in the browser.
- Pitch deck
- 36 seconds
- Water cycle deck
- 53 seconds
- Business review
- 64 seconds
- Median
- 53 seconds
- Remark
- Scale 5: median under 1 minute.
Raw notes
The clock ran from pressing Generate Presentation to the finished deck open in the browser. SlidesPilot shows no outline step to confirm: the page reads "Generating with AI..." and then opens the deck.
The pitch deck took 36 seconds, the water cycle deck 53 and the business review 64. The median is 53 seconds. No generation failed or stalled.
The page says "This may take 1-2 minutes"; none of the three took that long. A slide costs 1 credit, so the decks cost 10, 17 and 10 credits.
- Times come from the screen recordings, one run per brief.
Pricing & Value
5/5Tested- Method
- Plans were read in the plan box inside the app, in both billing views.
- Cheapest plan with export, monthly
- $9
- Same plan, billed yearly
- $8 a month
- Remark
- Scale 5: free, or under $10 a month.
Raw notes
Plans were read in the plan box inside the app, in both billing views.
The cheapest plan that downloads a PowerPoint file is Starter at $9 a month, or $8 a month billed yearly, with 300 credits a month. Plus is $19 or $15 billed yearly for 1,000 credits, and Pro is $39 or $23.33 billed yearly for 2,500.
The free plan gives 80 credits and blocks every download. All three paid plans list "3-day money-back guarantee", while the Terms say "THERE ARE NO REFUNDS".
- No plan was bought, so I did not see whether a paid export carries any mark.
Other features checked
Coverage
Tested
- The three fixed briefs, each typed once with the slide count in the brief text, timed from pressing Generate to the finished deck
- Seven structure points on each deck, every slide of all three decks checked for layout faults, every figure in the business review compared with my table, and the 15 key points in the pitch deck
- Twelve fixed edits on the business review deck, with the image swap done on the pitch deck
- The theme editor, the Download menu, the plan box in both billing views and the Terms
Not tested or limited
- Brand control was not graded: the theme editor takes hex colours but Save theme opens the upgrade box, so a custom theme cannot be kept on the free plan, and I found no way to import a .pptx template
- Export fidelity was not graded: PDF, PowerPoint, Google Slides and PNG all open the upgrade box on the free plan
- The Montserrat font is not in the font list; the closest is Montserrat Alternates
- Trustpilot returned no page for slidespilot.com on 5 November 2026, so no user score is quoted
- Text contrast was read by eye, not measured with a checker
- No plan was bought, so a paid export was never opened
- The Length setting read Auto when I pressed Generate on all three briefs, although the kit typed the count into the Custom slides field; the slide count SlidesPilot had was the one in the brief text (10, 12 and 10). I did not rerun the water cycle brief with the Custom count confirmed.
- SlidesPilot has no public pricing page: slidespilot.com/pricing sends a signed-out visitor to the login page, so the price tracker cannot read the plan box; the prices are my reading of 5 November 2026 in both billing views.
Still to test
- Brand control and the template import on a paid month
- Export fidelity to PowerPoint, Google Slides and PDF on a paid month
- A second run of the business review to see whether the invented figures repeat
- Real-time collaboration with a second account