Test log
SlidesGPT test data
Raw results for the SlidesGPT review. The verdict is in the review.
- Tested
- 6 November 2026
- Tester
- Miles Foster
- Account
- Free demo account, signed up by RankDude, nothing paid to the brand
- Tests
- 10
- Screenshots
- 10
- Method
- Published methodology
- Environment
- Google Chrome on desktop
Results
| ID | Test | Key measurement | Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| T01 | Export Fidelity | – | n/a |
| T02 | Structure from a Prompt | Structure points met: 17 of 21 | 4/5 |
| T03 | Slide Design | Layout faults: 29 | 2/5 |
| T04 | Content Accuracy | Figures from the brief that were wrong: 0 | 2/5 |
| T05 | Use of a Supplied Document | Key points covered: 11 of 15 | 2/5 |
| T06 | Editing Control | Edits that worked: 8 of 12 | 3/5 |
| T07 | Brand & Theme Control | Slides off-brand: more than 6 of 39 | 2/5 |
| T08 | Charts & Images | Bar chart values right: 8 of 8 | 3/5 |
| T09 | Speed | Brief to finished deck, median: 36 seconds | 5/5 |
| T10 | Pricing & Value | Cheapest plan with export, billed yearly: $7.49 a month | 5/5 |
| Overall (in the review) | 3.9/5 | ||
Export Fidelity
n/aNot Tested- Method
- Export each deck to PowerPoint, Google Slides and PDF and compare slide by slide.
- Remark
- Not graded; left out of the average.
Raw notes
Export each deck to PowerPoint, Google Slides and PDF and compare slide by slide.
Not run: choosing Download opens an upgrade box with PowerPoint, Google Slides and PDF downloads as the Pro plan’s main feature.
- Needs a paid plan.
Structure from a Prompt
4/5Tested- Method
- The three fixed briefs were each checked against the seven-point list in the methodology: the requested slide count within one, a title slide, an agenda, a logical order, one idea per slide, a conclusion or ask, and no repeated slide.
- Structure points met
- 17 of 21
- Slides asked, slides made
- 10 and 12, 12 and 14, 10 and 12
- Remark
- Scale 4: 17 to 19 of 21 points.
Raw notes
The three fixed briefs were each checked against the seven-point list in the methodology: the requested slide count within one, a title slide, an agenda, a logical order, one idea per slide, a conclusion or ask, and no repeated slide.
The quarterly review met five of seven. I asked for ten slides and got twelve, and both the title slide and the agenda appear twice: a cover with a photo and then a second title slide, an agenda list and then an agenda of icons.
The water cycle deck met six of seven: fourteen slides for a twelve-slide brief, because a cover and an agenda were added on top of the twelve topics. The pitch deck also met six: twelve slides for a ten-slide brief.
- The outline step listed exactly the slides I asked for, but the finished deck added a cover and an agenda on top in every brief. The Number of slides setting on the outline screen was left on Auto, so I did not test whether setting it to ten keeps the count.
Slide Design
2/5Tested- Method
- All 38 slides of the three first drafts were captured at 2x in the editor and checked for text overflowing its box, overlaps, contrast, misalignment, mixed fonts, walls of text and unrelated images.
- Layout faults
- 29
- Faults per 10 slides
- 7.6
- Remark
- Scale 2: 5 to 9.9 faults per 10 slides.
Raw notes
All 38 slides of the three first drafts were captured at 2x in the editor and checked for text overflowing its box, overlaps, contrast, misalignment, mixed fonts, walls of text and unrelated images. Text colours were read from the page and the contrast ratio worked out for flat backgrounds.
Twenty-nine faults in 38 slides, which is 7.6 in ten. The biggest is contrast: the grey subtitle on ten quarterly review slides is 2.5 to 1 on its background, and the coral subtitle on twelve water cycle slides is 1.6 to 1. Both are far under the 3 to 1 that large text needs.
The pitch deck had five: a bullet with a stray colon on its own line, two photos that have nothing to do with coffee (a glowing necklace of beads and a glass tablet with a tree on it), a chart whose axis text is tiny, and a cover title over a busy photo. The quarterly review and water cycle covers put white title text over a photo too, which I judged by eye.
- Faults were counted by eye at one window size, with the contrast of flat colours measured. Photos behind text were judged by eye.
Content Accuracy
2/5Tested- Method
- Every figure in the quarterly review was compared with the table in the brief, and every claim in the water cycle deck was read against general reference knowledge of the water cycle; the two reference pages the methodology names were not opened during this run.
- Figures from the brief that were wrong
- 0
- Invented figures
- 3
- Remark
- Scale 2: four to six errors, or any invented figure.
Raw notes
Every figure in the quarterly review was compared with the table in the brief, and every claim in the water cycle deck was read against general reference knowledge of the water cycle; the two reference pages the methodology names were not opened during this run.
Every figure that came from my table was right: $1,368k against $1,214k, the three months, the four regions, 41 per cent margin and 4.6 out of 5. But the summary slide shows rings reading 100%, 89% and 92%, and none of those numbers is in the brief, which said not to invent any. The 12.7 per cent growth figure I gave never appears on a slide.
The water cycle deck had no errors that I found. I counted the three percentages as invented figures.
- The water cycle facts were checked from reference knowledge by eye, not against the two named source pages.
Use of a Supplied Document
2/5Tested- Method
- The six-page Harbor Light Coffee Roasters memo was uploaded as a PDF with the prompt "Create a 10-slide investor pitch deck from the attached document." Each of the 15 key points I listed beforehand was checked as present and correct, distorted or missing.
- Key points covered
- 11 of 15
- Invented items
- 5
- Remark
- Scale 2: 4 to 7 points, or anything invented.
Raw notes
The six-page Harbor Light Coffee Roasters memo was uploaded as a PDF with the prompt "Create a 10-slide investor pitch deck from the attached document." Each of the 15 key points I listed beforehand was checked as present and correct, distorted or missing.
Eleven of 15 points were covered. Four were missing or cut in half: the subscription cadence (every two weeks or monthly), the 8 per cent market growth, the $2.1 million revenue figure (in the speaker notes only, not on a slide) and the lifetime value of $410 against $62 to win a subscriber.
Several things were not in the document: rings reading 83% and 79%, and a milestone slide dated Q1 2026, Q2 2027 and Q4 2028. The upload itself worked without trouble.
- The 15 points were listed before the test; one deck was run.
Editing Control
3/5Tested- Method
- Twelve fixed edits on the quarterly review deck.
- Edits that worked
- 8 of 12
- AI edit time
- 12 seconds
- Remark
- Scale 3: 7 to 9 of 12.
Raw notes
Twelve fixed edits on the quarterly review deck. An edit counts when it did what was asked with a normal control and no workaround.
Eight of twelve worked: slides reordered by drag, one layout changed (next steps became a roadmap), one slide regenerated, a risks slide shortened by the AI edit box, a slide inserted by AI between two others, an image replaced from a stock search, speaker notes edited in place, and a custom theme applied across the deck.
Four did not. The charts have no data table, and asking the AI to change one West value rewrote all eight numbers. Text can be edited but objects cannot be moved freely. There is no undo for three steps (only an Undo button for the last image change). I found no way to leave a comment for a collaborator.
The regenerated monthly chart turned July and August to 0, and the inserted slide carried placeholder text ("Item 2", "Description").
- The edits were done on one deck. No credit meter was shown and I did not hit a limit.
Brand & Theme Control
2/5Tested- Method
- I built a custom theme with the brand name, two hex colours (#0B3C5D and #F2A900), the font Montserrat and the Northwind logo, applied it to the three decks and checked every slide for the right logo, colours and font.
- Slides off-brand
- more than 6 of 39
- Template import
- not run
- Remark
- Scale 2: six or more slides off-brand.
Raw notes
I built a custom theme with the brand name, two hex colours (#0B3C5D and #F2A900), the font Montserrat and the Northwind logo, applied it to the three decks and checked every slide for the right logo, colours and font.
The font and the two colours reached the text, icons and rings on every slide. The logo appeared as a small mark at the bottom left of 12 of 13 slides of the quarterly review, but not on the cover. On the water cycle and pitch decks, choosing the saved theme from the list gave the colours and font and no logo.
The charts kept their own colours (purple and yellow) on the quarterly review and the pitch deck. The gold subtitle on white is 2.0 to 1. More than six slides were off-brand.
- The Upload master template button accepts a .pptx file; I had no template, so import was not tried. It is not clear whether the logo reaches a deck whose theme was chosen before the logo was added.
Charts & Images
3/5Tested- Method
- The brief asked for a bar chart, a line chart and a KPI panel.
- Bar chart values right
- 8 of 8
- Charts as asked
- 2 of 3
- Remark
- Scale 3: one chart wrong.
Raw notes
The brief asked for a bar chart, a line chart and a KPI panel. Each value was checked, each chart was clicked to see whether it has data behind it, and every image in the decks was checked for relevance and for a stated source.
The bar chart of revenue by region had all eight values right. The monthly revenue chart was a bar chart, not the line chart I asked for, and a request to regenerate it as a line chart left July and August at 0. The KPI panel was made, with the invented percentages.
Clicking a chart opens no data table. Stock photos found in the editor show a credit ("Photo by Aleksandr Kozlovskii on Unsplash"); the AI-made pictures show an empty "Click to add caption" and no source. One was off-topic in the pitch deck.
- Counted as one chart wrong and static charts; the quarterly review was checked closely.
Speed
5/5Tested- Method
- Each brief was typed in the create box and sent.
- Brief to finished deck, median
- 36 seconds
- Outline to finished deck
- 24, 24 and 21 seconds
- Remark
- Scale 5: median under 1 minute.
Raw notes
Each brief was typed in the create box and sent. The clock ran from pressing Create Slides, through the outline and Show Slides, to the page text no longer changing. The outline step and the build step were timed separately.
All three decks took 36 seconds. The outline was ready after 12 seconds for the quarterly review and the water cycle deck and 15 for the pitch deck, and the deck itself took 24, 24 and 21 seconds more.
There was no credit price on the outline screen and no meter on the free plan.
- The clock stopped when the page text last changed; late images are possible.
Pricing & Value
5/5Tested- Method
- Plans were read on the public pricing page in both billing views and in the upgrade box that opens from Download.
- Cheapest plan with export, billed yearly
- $7.49 a month
- Same plan, monthly
- $9.99
- Remark
- Scale 5: free, or under $10 a month, for the cheapest plan that exports a .pptx file.
Raw notes
Plans were read on the public pricing page in both billing views and in the upgrade box that opens from Download.
The cheapest plan that exports a PowerPoint file is Pro at $9.99 a month, or $7.49 a month billed yearly ($89.99 a year). It allows 10 downloads a month and 30 AI images. Pro XL is $29.99 a month, or $22.50 billed yearly ($269.99), with 50 downloads.
The free plan creates, views and shares decks. The upgrade box lists Visa, Mastercard, American Express and PayPal through Stripe.
- No plan was bought, so I did not see a paid export or whether it carries a watermark.
Other features checked
Coverage
Tested
- The three fixed briefs typed with the slide count left to the tool, the outline confirmed and each deck timed
- Seven structure points, layout faults counted on all 38 slides, every figure against the table, 15 key points against the PDF
- Twelve fixed edits on the quarterly review deck, by hand and with the AI edit box
- A custom theme with the brand logo, colours and font applied to all three decks
- Download menu, upgrade box, public pricing page and Terms of Service read; Trustpilot profile read
Not tested or limited
- Export fidelity was not graded: PowerPoint, PDF and Google Slides all open the upgrade box on the free plan
- The .pptx template import was not run: the theme panel has an Upload master template button, but I had no template file, so the brand grade rests on the custom theme alone
- Presentation mode and AI image generation are paid features and were not used
- The clock stopped when the page text stopped changing, so a late image could arrive after it
- The create box has no slide count field, so each brief carries its count in the prompt. The outline screen has a Number of slides setting that I left on Auto; the outline listed the count I asked for and the finished deck added a cover and an agenda on top.
- Text contrast on slides with a photo behind the title was judged by eye; the flat colours were measured
Still to test
- Export fidelity to PowerPoint, Google Slides and PDF on a paid month
- The .pptx master template import with a real template
- Presentation mode and AI image generation
- Real-time collaboration with a second account
- The Number of slides setting on the outline screen, set to the brief’s count