Test log
PopAi test data
Raw results for the PopAi review. The verdict is in the review.
- Tested
- 6 November 2026
- Tester
- Miles Foster
- Account
- Free demo account, signed up by RankDude, nothing paid to the brand
- Tests
- 10
- Screenshots
- 8
- Method
- Published methodology
- Environment
- Google Chrome on desktop
Results
| ID | Test | Key measurement | Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| T01 | Use of a Supplied Document | – | n/a |
| T02 | Brand & Theme Control | – | n/a |
| T03 | Export Fidelity | – | n/a |
| T04 | Structure from a Prompt | Structure points met: 6 of 7 | 4/5 |
| T05 | Slide Design | Layout faults: 2 | 3/5 |
| T06 | Content Accuracy | Figures checked: all five slides and the plan | 5/5 |
| T07 | Editing Control | Edits that worked: 4 of 12 | 2/5 |
| T08 | Charts & Images | Chart values right: 11 of 11 | 4/5 |
| T09 | Speed | Enter to finished deck: 129 seconds | 3/5 |
| T10 | Pricing & Value | – | 3/5 |
| Overall (in the review) | 3.4/5 | ||
Use of a Supplied Document
n/aNot Tested- Method
- Build the pitch deck from the six-page document and check 15 key points.
- Remark
- Not graded; left out of the average.
Raw notes
Build the pitch deck from the six-page document and check 15 key points.
Not run: the one ten-slide deck used all 250 free credits, and the next request asks for an upgrade.
- Needs credits.
Brand & Theme Control
n/aNot Tested- Method
- Add the logo, the two colours and the font, import the template, then check every slide.
- Remark
- Not graded; left out of the average.
Raw notes
Add the logo, the two colours and the font, import the template, then check every slide.
Not run: a branded deck needs a new deck, and no credits were left. AI PowerPoint, the mode for custom templates, also needs credits.
- Needs credits.
Export Fidelity
n/aNot Tested- Method
- Export each deck to PowerPoint, Google Slides and PDF and compare slide by slide.
- Remark
- Not graded; left out of the average.
Raw notes
Export each deck to PowerPoint, Google Slides and PDF and compare slide by slide.
Not run: the Download box offers PowerPoint, marked Plus, and PDF, and the download button stays grey on the free plan.
- Needs a paid plan.
Structure from a Prompt
4/5Tested- Method
- The quarterly review brief for Northwind Cycle Co.
- Structure points met
- 6 of 7
- Slides
- 10 of 10
- Remark
- Scale 4: 17 to 19 of 21 points. With one deck the thresholds are scaled to 7 points, so 6 of 7 is the second-highest grade.
Raw notes
The quarterly review brief for Northwind Cycle Co. asked for ten slides: a title slide, an agenda, a bar chart of revenue by region, a line chart of monthly revenue, a KPI slide, risks, next steps and a closing ask. The first draft was checked against the seven-point list in the methodology. The free plan blurs slides 6 to 10, so those five were checked from the plan the agent wrote in the chat before it built them.
Six of seven points were met: ten slides, a title slide, an agenda, a logical order from Q3 results to Q4 focus, one idea per slide and a closing ask on slide 10. The point that failed is no repeated slides: slide 9, "The Q3 Pattern Supports Continued Focus on Growth Quality", lists the same revenue, order and customer figures that slides 3, 4 and 6 already show.
The brief asked for a risks slide and the plan has one, slide 7, "The Main Risks Are Concentrated in Regional Performance and Service Load".
- One deck only, and slides 6 to 10 were read from the plan, not from finished slides, because the free plan blurs them.
Slide Design
3/5Tested- Method
- Slides 1 to 5 were captured at 2x in the editor, 864 pixels wide, and checked for text overflowing its box, overlaps, misalignment, mixed fonts, walls of text and unrelated images.
- Layout faults
- 2
- Slides checked
- 5
- Faults per 10 slides
- 4.0
- Remark
- Scale 3: 3 to 4.9 faults per 10 slides.
Raw notes
Slides 1 to 5 were captured at 2x in the editor, 864 pixels wide, and checked for text overflowing its box, overlaps, misalignment, mixed fonts, walls of text and unrelated images. Slides 6 to 10 are blurred on the free plan and could not be checked. Faults were counted and expressed per ten slides.
Two faults in five slides. The chart axis titles, "Revenue($k)" on slide 3 and "($k)" on slide 5, are set in text far smaller than the rest of the slide, and the line chart on slide 3 has no value labels.
There were no walls of text, no overlaps and one font family. The look is dark blue with white headings and plenty of space.
- Only five slides could be checked. Faults were counted by eye at one window size; text contrast was not measured with a checker.
Content Accuracy
5/5Tested- Method
- Every figure on slides 1 to 5 was compared with the table in the brief, and the figures in the plan for slides 6 to 10 were compared too: three months of revenue, orders, new customers and support tickets, revenue by region for Q2 and Q3, the totals, margin and satisfaction.
- Figures checked
- all five slides and the plan
- Errors
- 0
- Remark
- Scale 5: no errors, nothing invented.
Raw notes
Every figure on slides 1 to 5 was compared with the table in the brief, and the figures in the plan for slides 6 to 10 were compared too: three months of revenue, orders, new customers and support tickets, revenue by region for Q2 and Q3, the totals, margin and satisfaction.
Every figure matched the table: $1,368k against $1,214k, up 12.7 per cent; July, August and September at $412k, $455k and $501k; the orders, customers and tickets for each month; North, South, East and West at 388 and 452, 301 and 365, 274 and 331, 251 and 220; 41 per cent margin and 4.6 out of 5.
The only thing not in the brief was a date on the title slide, "November 5, 2026", which is the day the deck was made in the United States. I did not count it as an error.
- Slides 6 to 10 were checked from the plan the agent wrote, not from the finished slides.
Editing Control
2/5Tested- Method
- Twelve fixed edits on the quarterly review deck.
- Edits that worked
- 4 of 12
- Edits blocked by credits
- 4
- Remark
- Scale 2: 4 to 6.
Raw notes
Twelve fixed edits on the quarterly review deck. An edit counts when it did what was asked with a normal control and no workaround.
Four worked: slides reordered by dragging in the strip, a blank card inserted between two slides, a chart's data edited in its data sheet, and the theme changed across the whole deck in one click.
Eight did not. Change layout, regenerate a slide, shorten a paragraph and replace an image all need credits, and the box answered "No credits remaining. Please upgrade to continue using." I found no speaker notes, no way to move a chart freely (it only resizes), no step-by-step undo (Ctrl+Z did nothing; Version history restores a saved version) and no comment: the Collaborate box invites people by email and I did not invite anyone.
- Four edits were blocked because one deck had used all the credits, so a paid month could score higher. A chart's data was edited in the same deck, and the deck was restored from version history afterwards.
Charts & Images
4/5Tested- Method
- The brief asked for a bar chart, a line chart and a KPI panel.
- Chart values right
- 11 of 11
- First-draft charts with editable data
- 2 of 2
- Remark
- Scale 4: charts correct, one weak image or one chart not checked.
Raw notes
The brief asked for a bar chart, a line chart and a KPI panel. Each value was checked, and each chart was clicked to see whether it is a chart with data behind it. The one picture on the title slide was checked for relevance and source.
Both charts I could see were right: three values in the line chart and eight in the bar chart. Clicking a chart shows Edit Chart, a chart type menu, Legend Position and a Value switch, and Edit Chart opens a data sheet with 18 chart types.
I could not check the KPI panel: slide 6 is blurred on the free plan. The glowing growth curve on the title slide suits the deck and shows no source or licence, and the line chart has no value labels until you switch them on.
- The KPI panel on slide 6 was not seen. Only one deck was checked.
Speed
3/5Tested- Method
- The brief was typed into AI Slides and sent with Enter.
- Enter to finished deck
- 129 seconds
- Credits for the deck
- 347
- Remark
- Scale 3: 2 to 3.9 minutes.
Raw notes
The brief was typed into AI Slides and sent with Enter. PopAi has no outline step to confirm: the agent writes a plan in the chat and builds the deck by itself. The clock ran from Enter to the last slide finished, read from the screen recording.
The deck was finished about 129 seconds after Enter. While it built, the right side showed grey blocks and the left side showed the agent's task list.
The deck used 347 credits, which the credit box reports as "347/250" with "0/250" remaining. The cost is not shown before you press Enter.
- One deck only, so the median is that one run. The start time is read from a recording to the nearest few seconds.
Pricing & Value
3/5Tested- Method
- I opened the Pricing link and the upgrade box from the editor.
- Remark
- Default grade of 3 because the plans could not be read.
Raw notes
I opened the Pricing link and the upgrade box from the editor. Both show a Cloudflare "Verify you are human" check in place of the plans. I did not pass it.
I could not read any paid plan, so there is no monthly cost for a PowerPoint export and no price on this page. The free plan gives 250 credits, and the Download box marks PowerPoint as Plus.
The grade is the default 3 for a test that could not be run, not a measured one.
- No plan prices, credit packs or renewal terms were seen. The price tracker could not be set up for the same reason.
Other features checked
Coverage
Tested
- The quarterly review brief typed into AI Slides and timed from Enter to the last slide
- Seven structure points, layout faults, every figure against the table and two charts checked on the five slides the free plan shows
- Twelve fixed edits tried with the editor's normal controls
- Credit box, Download box, upgrade box and Terms of Use read
Not tested or limited
- Only one of the three fixed briefs was graded: the quarterly review used 347 of 250 credits, so no credits were left for the water cycle or pitch deck. I could not stop at 85 per cent because the cost is not shown before you press Enter
- From slide 6 the free plan shows a blurred preview with the words "Blurred preview from page 6 onward". I checked slides 1 to 5 on screen and read slides 6 to 10 from the plan the agent wrote in the chat, so the KPI slide and the closing slide were not seen as finished slides
- The pitch deck from a six-page document was not run, so use of a supplied document was not graded
- Brand control was not graded: it needs a second deck, and no credits were left
- Export fidelity was not graded: the Download button for PowerPoint is marked Plus and stays grey on the free plan
- Pricing could not be read: the upgrade box shows a Cloudflare "Verify you are human" check that I did not pass. The pricing grade is the default 3
- Text contrast was read by eye, not measured with a checker
Still to test
- The water cycle and pitch briefs on a paid month, with the supplied PDF
- Brand kit and template import (AI PowerPoint mode) on a paid month
- Export fidelity to PowerPoint, Google Slides and PDF on a paid month
- Real-time collaboration with a second account, and the pricing page once it can be read