Poe Review: AI Chatbot, Pricing & My Test Results

My rating
An accurate chatbot. A spreadsheet failed to send twice.
Best for: facts, maths, code and writing. Not for: spreadsheets, audio or images on the free allowance.

Tested and written by Miles Foster
Based on 10 graded tests and my verdict. How I rate
I tested Poe hands-on with the same battery I give every AI chatbot: fact questions, reasoning problems, coding tasks, writing briefs, images and files. I used the free plan and its default bot, Assistant, and I started a fresh chat for every prompt. Poe ranks #4 of the ten on my best AI chatbots page.
Every count and answer is in the Poe test results.
My Poe AI Chatbot Test Results
| Category | Grade | In short |
|---|---|---|
| Answer Accuracy & HallucinationEvery fact right, nothing invented | 5/5Excellent | |
| Reasoning & MathsSolved every problem with clear working | 5/5Excellent | |
| CodingAll code ran and passed first time | 5/5Excellent | |
| Following Instructions & WritingMet every constraint in every brief | 5/5Excellent | |
| Context & Long-Document MemoryNot tested: 3 by default | 3/5Average | |
| Web Access & CitationsNot tested: 3 by default | 3/5Average | |
| Images, Files & VoiceRead most images and files, spreadsheet failed | 4/5Good | |
| Safety & RefusalsNot tested: 3 by default | 3/5Average | |
| Response SpeedNot tested: 3 by default | 3/5Average | |
| Pricing & ValueNot tested: 3 by default | 3/5Average | |
| My verdict | +0.7 | |
| Overall | 4.6/5Excellent |
What Is Poe?
Poe is an AI chatbot web app at poe.com. It is a front door to many bots and models, and you pick a bot or let the default bot, Assistant, choose for you.
I tested only Assistant. The chat never shows which model replied, and the bot's page says it routes each request automatically, so I can only tell you what Assistant did.
How I Tested Poe
Every chatbot gets the same fixed battery, and I keep the first answer to every prompt. I used the default bot Assistant with memory off and started a fresh chat for each prompt.
My tools
The free plan's daily points ran out on 7 November, so I ran the battery in two sittings, on 7 and 9 November. I bought nothing. The long document, web, safety, speed and pricing tests did not run, and each counts as 3 by default.
Poe pros and cons
Pros
- Every fact question right
- All ten code tasks passed
- Every writing constraint met
- Rejected all five false premises
- Read photos, a PDF and handwriting
- Asked which length when a brief contradicted itself
Cons
- Spreadsheet message failed to send
- No image creation on the free allowance
- Audio clip refused
- No model name shown in answers
- Copied code loses its indentation
Poe Pricing
- Pricing & Value
- 3/5Average
Poe has a free plan with 300 points a day, and every answer spends some of them. A short answer cost a few points, an image question 11 to 44, and a web search answer 119, which emptied the allowance on 7 November.
Poe plans and prices
| Plan | Price a month | |
|---|---|---|
| Free300 points a day; subscriptions showed as unavailable in my region | $0 | 300 points a day; subscriptions showed as unavailable in my region |
| SubscriptionOffered by Subscribe to continue; no checkout was available in my region | Paid | Offered by Subscribe to continue; no checkout was available in my region |
The Subscribe to continue panel listed yearly plans, but subscriptions were unavailable in my region, so I read no checkout and give no prices. Prices change, so check the plan page before you pay.
Poe Accuracy and Invented Facts
- Answer Accuracy & Hallucination
- 5/5Excellent
Poe's Assistant answered all 30 fact questions correctly and invented nothing. It rejected all five questions built on a false premise, such as a Dickens novel that does not exist.
Ask when Einstein served as a head of state and it tells you he never did, and that he was offered a presidency in 1952 and declined.
Poe Reasoning and Maths
- Reasoning & Maths
- 5/5Excellent
Assistant solved all 15 reasoning and maths problems. It got the three trap problems right, such as the snail that reaches the top on day 9 because it does not slip back on the last day.
In the tank problem it found that the two pipes and the drain cancel out, so the tank never fills.
Poe Coding
- Coding
- 5/5Excellent
Assistant wrote code that passed all ten of my checks the first time. When I asked for tests of its own, they passed on correct code and caught all three deliberately broken versions.
Poe's page loses the indentation when you copy code, so I restored it by hand. I changed no logic, but you may need to do the same.
Poe Following Instructions
- Following Instructions & Writing
- 5/5Excellent
Assistant met every constraint in all 15 briefs. A paragraph that had to be exactly 60 words was exactly 60, and an email ended with "Thanks, Alex" on its own final line.
The brief that contradicts itself got the right reply: it said an exact 20-word paragraph cannot also be at least 100 words, and asked which length I wanted.
Poe Images and Files
- Images, Files & Voice
- 4/5Good
Assistant passed seven of eight image and file points I ran. It read a photo, a chart, a notice, handwriting (with one added comma), a maths problem, a PDF and a table image.
When I asked for the head lifeguard in the PDF, it said the document does not name one, so you do not get an invented name.
The spreadsheet failed. The message with the file failed to send twice, and nothing was read from it. I did not try it again on 9 November.
Image creation was not offered. A request for an image was priced at 2,759 points when I had 167, and Poe asked me to subscribe. The audio clip was refused too.
Final verdict: is Poe worth it?
Poe is worth trying if you want an accurate chatbot for facts, maths, code and writing, from one account. Everything I could count was right.
It is a weaker fit if you need spreadsheets, audio or images from the free allowance, or if you want to know which model answered, because Assistant does not say.
The ten tests average 3.9 out of 5, five of them not run and counted as 3. I add 0.7 because every answer it gave in the graded tests was right and the 300-point free daily allowance was never used up in about 63 messages. I rate it 4.6. If you do not need spreadsheets or images from the free plan, it fits.
See the Poe test results and how I rate.
Best for: People who want an accurate chatbot for facts, maths, code and writing from one free account.
Video review · 2:53
Watch me test Poe
The whole test in about three minutes: facts, reasoning, code, writing briefs, images and files. Captions and the full transcript are one click away, and the video has a page of its own.
Transcript
Hi, I'm Miles. I tested Poe, an AI chatbot, with the same fixed battery I give every chatbot, on the free plan. Here's the short version. Its default bot got every fact, reasoning problem, code task and writing brief right. A spreadsheet failed to send, though, and it would not make images. My rating is four point six out of five.
So what is Poe? It's a web app that gives you many chatbots in one place. I tested only the default bot, called Assistant. The chat never shows which model replied, so I can only tell you what Assistant did.
Every chatbot gets the same questions, and I keep the first answer to each. I started a fresh chat for every prompt. The free daily points ran out on the seventh, so I ran the rest two days later. I bought nothing. Five tests did not run at all, the long document, web, safety, speed and pricing, and each counts as three by default.
On facts, Assistant got all thirty right and invented nothing. It rejected all five questions built on a false premise, like a Dickens novel that does not exist, and Edison's radio telescope finding Pluto.
It solved all fifteen reasoning problems. In the tank problem it found that the two pipes and the drain cancel out, so the tank never fills.
All ten code tasks passed first time. When I asked for tests of its own, they caught all three deliberately broken versions of the code. One thing to know: copying code from the page loses the indentation, so I put it back by hand.
On writing briefs, it met every constraint in all fifteen. A paragraph that had to be exactly sixty words was exactly sixty. When I gave it a brief that contradicts itself, it said so and asked which length I wanted.
It read a photo, a chart, handwriting, a maths problem, a PDF and a table image correctly. When I asked for the head lifeguard in the PDF, it said the document does not name one. But the spreadsheet message failed to send twice, and I did not try it again. Image creation and audio were not offered on the free allowance.
There is a free plan with three hundred points a day, and every answer spends some. A web search answer cost one hundred and nineteen, and that emptied my allowance. Subscriptions were unavailable in my region, so I read no checkout and give no prices.
So, is it worth trying? Yes, if you want an accurate chatbot for facts, maths, code and writing. The weak spots are the spreadsheet that failed to send and the missing image creation. The ten tests average three point nine, five of them not run and counted as three. I added zero point seven because every answer it gave in the graded tests was right, and the free daily allowance was never used up. My rating is four point six out of five.
Chapters · 12
Frequently asked questions
Is Poe free?
Yes, I used the free plan. It gives 300 points a day, and the allowance ran out on 7 November during one session. I bought nothing, and subscriptions were unavailable in my region, so I read no checkout.
Is Poe accurate?
Yes, on what I ran. The default bot got 30 of 30 fact questions and 15 of 15 reasoning problems right, and rejected five false premises.
Which model did I test?
Assistant. The default bot. Answers do not show a model. The bot's page says it routes automatically, so I can only describe what Assistant did.
Can Poe make images?
Not for me. Each image request was priced at 2,759 points when I had 167 left, and Poe asked me to subscribe.
Can Poe read files and images?
Mostly. It read a photo, a chart, handwriting, a PDF and a table image correctly. The spreadsheet message failed to send twice.
How did I rate Poe?
4.6 out of 5. The ten tests average 3.9, with five not run and counted as 3. I added 0.7 because every answer it gave in the graded tests was right and the 300-point free daily allowance was never used up in about 63 messages.
Miles FosterOwner and tester, RankDudeMiles Foster is a pen name: the owner of RankDude, a private person, runs every test himself.
Disclosure. I tested on the free demo account anyone can open on Poe’s site. I signed up myself and paid Poe nothing. Poe didn’t see this review first and had no say in my rating. How RankDude makes money is on the disclosure page.