Test log
SmashingLogo test data
Raw results for the SmashingLogo review. The verdict is in the review.
- Tested
- 5 November 2026
- Tester
- Miles Foster
- Account
- Free demo account, signed up by RankDude, nothing paid to the brand
- Tests
- 10
- Screenshots
- 6
- Method
- Published methodology
- Environment
- Google Chrome on desktop
Results
| ID | Test | Key measurement | Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| T01 | Design Quality & Brief Fit | First logo, coffee brief: 25 seconds | n/a |
| T02 | Originality | – | n/a |
| T03 | Legibility at Small Sizes | – | n/a |
| T04 | Brand Kit Completeness | – | n/a |
| T05 | File Formats | – | n/a |
| T06 | Ease of Use & Speed | First logo, median of three briefs: 16 seconds | n/a |
| T07 | Variety of Concepts | Distinct ideas per brief: 11, 6 and 6 | 3/5 |
| T08 | Editing Control | Edits that worked: 10 of 10 | 5/5 |
| T09 | Usage Rights & Ownership | Rights in writing: 2 of 5 | 2/5 |
| T10 | Pricing & Value | Cheapest vector route: $49.99 once | 4/5 |
| Overall (in the review) | 3.9/5 | ||
Design Quality & Brief Fit
n/aNot Tested- Method
- The five best concepts of each brief are scored on an eight-point checklist by three outside judges.
- First logo, coffee brief
- 25 seconds
- First logo, law firm
- 16 seconds
- First logo, coding school
- 14 seconds
- Remark
- Not graded: the scale needs three outside judges and the previews carry a watermark.
Raw notes
The five best concepts of each brief are scored on an eight-point checklist by three outside judges. I checked the parts I can see myself: the name, the tagline and the colours to avoid.
Name and tagline: spelled right on every concept I looked at for all three briefs (Harbour Bean, Calloway & Reed, Pixel Pioneers).
Colours to avoid: the wizard has no field for them, only up to two colour swatches. The brown and gold coffee logo held no purple or neon green, but the Geometric tile for the coffee brief used purple and green. The Mascot and Geometric tiles for the law firm used orange. The Mascot and Geometric tiles for the coding school used black lettering.
The wizard's Suggested For You tab shows a font style, two colour swatches and eight icon style tiles, and no suggested icon: the tiles carry the same hammer-and-pencil pictures for all three briefs. The first coffee logo was a coffee cup in a hand. A second run with the same answers gave a letter H with a bean.
The wizard offered no 'craft', so the coffee brief ran with warm, honest and authentic.
- No outside judges were used.
Originality
n/aNot Tested- Method
- Reverse image searches and a trademark image search of the top concepts.
- Remark
- Not graded.
Raw notes
Reverse image searches and a trademark image search of the top concepts.
Not run: every preview carries a repeated watermark, so a search would not match the logo you could buy.
- Run again on a paid, unwatermarked file.
Legibility at Small Sizes
n/aNot Tested- Method
- The saved logo for each brief is shrunk to 16, 32 and 64 pixels.
- Remark
- Not graded: there is no file to test.
Raw notes
The saved logo for each brief is shrunk to 16, 32 and 64 pixels.
Not run: no file was saved. A screenshot of the watermarked preview is not the file you download, so I did not shrink one.
- Needs the free download or a paid file.
Brand Kit Completeness
n/aNot Tested- Method
- Ten-point checklist of the downloaded package.
- Remark
- Not graded: I do not grade what I did not open.
Raw notes
Ten-point checklist of the downloaded package.
Not run: no package was downloaded. The plans page lists branding guidelines, a social media kit and extra colour versions with Business, and a business card design, an email signature and web design concepts with Ultimate.
- Needs a bought package.
File Formats
n/aNot Tested- Method
- Each downloaded file is opened and measured.
- Remark
- Not graded: no file was opened.
Raw notes
Each downloaded file is opened and measured.
Not run: the free download needs an email address at a checkout that shows a total of $0, and I did not enter one.
The plans page lists an "Ultra-High-Resolution File" for Essentials, and "Web-Ready Files", "Print-Ready Files" and "Transparent PNG Files" for Pro. Pro's Print-Ready Files item says you receive 'high-resolution vector formats (PDF and EPS)'. The terms say "Our Business and Premium package includes the raw vector files (PDF and EPS format)", and there is no Premium plan on the page.
- Needs the free download or a paid file.
Ease of Use & Speed
n/aNot Tested- Method
- The clock runs from opening the generator to the final files saved on disk.
- First logo, median of three briefs
- 16 seconds
- Remark
- Not graded: the scale measures time to a saved file.
Raw notes
The clock runs from opening the generator to the final files saved on disk.
Not graded: no file was saved. The first logo appeared 25.5 seconds after I pressed Continue on the coffee brief (25.2 seconds on a repeat), 16.3 seconds on the law brief and 14.2 seconds on the coding brief, after three short screens: about your brand, a style, and a starting point. No sign-up came first.
- Times are from my ledger of a manual run; no file was saved and no account was signed in.
- An earlier run that morning, abandoned part way, measured 19 to 38 seconds to a first logo (coffee-timing.json, coffee2-timing.json, law-timing.json, coding-timing.json in the evidence folder).
Variety of Concepts
3/5Tested- Method
- I counted distinct ideas in every concept of each brief (26, 25 and 25), by eye, with one rule: a different symbol or layout counts once; a colour change, a font change or a redraw of the same symbol does not.
- Distinct ideas per brief
- 11, 6 and 6
- Average
- 7.7
- Concepts made
- 76
- Remark
- Scale 3: 7 to 10 distinct ideas on average.
Raw notes
I counted distinct ideas in every concept of each brief (26, 25 and 25), by eye, with one rule: a different symbol or layout counts once; a colour change, a font change or a redraw of the same symbol does not. The grade is the average of the three briefs.
Coffee roaster: about 11 distinct ideas in 26 concepts. The cup in a hand, a bean in a wave circle, an outline bean, an engraved bean, a bean under a sun, a bean in a shield and a bean in a diamond were the clearest differences.
Law firm: about 6 distinct ideas in 25 concepts. Every one was a balance scale with olive branches, in a shield, a wreath, a coloured badge or a flat mark.
Coding school: about 6 distinct ideas in 25 concepts. Every one was a compass, with a globe or circuit lines, in a shield, a badge or a flat mark.
How they were made: after the first logo, Icon Explorer shows eight style tiles. The eight style tiles took about 40 seconds to fill, and a plus button adds another try in the same style. I saw no limit, token or credit counter. The archive counted 26, 25 and 25 concepts.
- Counted by eye by one person; another person might count a few more or fewer.
- The method counts the first 20; I counted all of them, which can only raise the figure.
Editing Control
5/5Tested- Method
- Ten fixed edits on the coffee roaster logo.
- Edits that worked
- 10 of 10
- Edits by AI prompt
- 1
- Remark
- Scale 5: all ten without a workaround.
Raw notes
Ten fixed edits on the coffee roaster logo. An edit counts when it did what was asked, with no workaround.
Worked (10): typeface (Instrument Sans Regular from a list of fonts with descriptions), colour by hex (#8B4513), icon above the name (switched to the icon beside the name, then back above), letter spacing (0 to 3), swap the icon (Icon Explorer, then Customize and Fine-tune in Advanced Editor), edit the icon's shape (the AI box: "make the cup rounder and the handle bigger" gave a rounder cup with a bigger handle and a saucer; a second try, "make the bean rounder and add a small leaf", added a leaf), add the tagline (removed it, then typed Roasted slow, poured fresh and saved), resize the icon against the name (size 5 to 9), a one-colour version (#000000) and undo back to the start (the undo button went grey).
Two things to know: swapping the icon started a new undo history, and an AI icon edit put the icon size back to its default.
- The edits were made on the watermarked free preview. The paid post-purchase editor was not tested.
Usage Rights & Ownership
2/5Tested- Method
- The terms of use (smashinglogo.com/en/terms-of-use, last updated September 17, 2026, read on 5 November 2026) are read for five rights.
- Rights in writing
- 2 of 5
- Remark
- Scale 2: commercial use and ownership, and not the other three.
Raw notes
The terms of use (smashinglogo.com/en/terms-of-use, last updated September 17, 2026, read on 5 November 2026) are read for five rights. A right counts only when the terms state it.
Commercial use: stated. "You can use the purchased logo for any commercial or non-commercial purpose."
Ownership: stated, with a catch. "You have the full ownership of the purchased design as a whole, not to the individual elements like the used fonts or icons." The same paragraph says "We retain the copyright and all associated rights to the original design."
Not sold to anyone else: not promised. The terms give the company a "worldwide, royalty-free, irrevocable, perpetual, non-exclusive license" to use your logo for its internal and marketing purposes.
Trademark registration: not granted. "No trademark, copyright or service marks are being conveyed under this license agreement." The Essentials card on the plans page says the logo is "100% yours to use, trademark, and protect", which the terms do not say.
Typefaces licensed for logo use: not stated. Ownership does not cover "the individual elements like the used fonts or icons", and the terms say "some fonts and symbols" may be licensed from a third party.
- Terms read by me, not a lawyer.
Pricing & Value
4/5Tested- Method
- Every plan is read from the page where the logo maker shows them (after pressing Download), not from a marketing page.
- Cheapest vector route
- $49.99 once
- Remark
- $30 to $59, one-off: 4.
Raw notes
Every plan is read from the page where the logo maker shows them (after pressing Download), not from a marketing page. The figure graded is the cheapest price for one logo with vector files and commercial rights.
The cheapest plan that names a vector file is Pro at $49.99 once: its Print-Ready Files item says you receive 'high-resolution vector formats (PDF and EPS)'. The terms put 'the raw vector files (PDF and EPS format)' with 'Business and Premium', and there is no Premium plan on the page, so the plans and the terms disagree.
Essentials is $29.99, Pro $49.99 and Ultimate $149.99, all once, each shown with a higher price crossed out and a "Pay Once. Use Forever." line. A countdown timer sits above the plans, and Business and Ultimate come with a bundle of extras valued at $159.99.
The plans say "30-Day Money Back Guarantee". The terms say that once you have access to the files you are "not eligible for a refund".
- No plan was bought, so the files in each plan were not checked.
Coverage
Tested
- The question wizard and the first logo for all three briefs, timed
- 25 or 26 concepts per brief in the Icon Explorer, counted and compared by eye
- All ten fixed edits on the coffee roaster logo, one by an AI prompt
- The terms of use, the privacy and contact pages, and the plans as shown after pressing Download
Not tested or limited
- No file was saved: the free download asks for an email address at a payment checkout, and I did not enter one. Small sizes, file formats, brand kit and time to a saved file could not be tested
- Design quality was not graded: it needs three outside judges, and the previews carry a watermark
- Originality searches were not run on watermarked previews
- No plan was bought, so the paid files, the vector files and the refund were not tested
- Distinct ideas were counted by eye, with one rule for all three briefs: a new symbol or layout counts once, a colour change or a redraw of the same symbol does not
- The wizard offered no 'craft', so the coffee brief ran with warm, honest and authentic
Still to test
- The free download or a bought Essentials file: small sizes, file formats and time to a saved file
- A bought Business package: vector files, branding guidelines and the social media kit
- Design quality with three outside judges, and originality searches on a clean file
- The refund against the 30-day money-back claim