Test log
Recraft test data
Raw results for the Recraft review. The verdict is in the review.
- Tested
- 5 November 2026
- Tester
- Miles Foster
- Account
- Free demo account, signed up by RankDude, nothing paid to the brand
- Tests
- 10
- Screenshots
- 8
- Method
- Published methodology
- Environment
- Google Chrome on desktop
Results
| ID | Test | Key measurement | Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| T01 | Design Quality & Brief Fit | Concepts made: 8 of 45 needed | n/a |
| T02 | Originality | – | n/a |
| T03 | Variety of Concepts | – | n/a |
| T04 | Editing Control | Edits that worked: 4 of 10 | n/a |
| T05 | Legibility at Small Sizes | Name readable from: 64 px | 4/5 |
| T06 | Brand Kit Completeness | Items in the law package: 6 of 10 | 3/5 |
| T07 | File Formats | Vector files: 8 SVG | 4/5 |
| T08 | Usage Rights & Ownership | Rights in writing on free: 0 of 5 | 1/5 |
| T09 | Ease of Use & Speed | Median time to files: 4 min 44 s | 5/5 |
| T10 | Pricing & Value | Cheapest paid route: $12 for one month | 4/5 |
| Overall (in the review) | 3.7/5 | ||
Design Quality & Brief Fit
n/aNot Tested- Method
- Two fixed briefs, typed into the Logo Maker's Start and Feel steps, with the style left to the agent's pick.
- Concepts made
- 8 of 45 needed
- Names spelled right
- 8 of 8
- Remark
- Not graded: the scale scores the five best of 20 concepts per brief on a 120-point checklist, and the free plan paid for four per brief.
Raw notes
Two fixed briefs, typed into the Logo Maker's Start and Feel steps, with the style left to the agent's pick. The brief's tagline and colours to avoid have no field in the wizard.
Coffee roaster, Handcrafted Type: four concepts (a roasting tray with beans, a lantern, a mooring bollard, a hand-lettered name). Name spelled right on all four; no tagline.
Family law firm, Refined Serif: four concepts (a heron, a knot of arches, a tree, two clasped hands in a circle). Name spelled right on all four; no tagline; the navy palette kept clear of red and orange.
The Logo Maker said "I can't add a tagline to the brief", so no logo carries the tagline.
- Outside judges were not used. The free plan paid for 8 concepts across two briefs.
Originality
n/aNot Tested- Method
- Reverse image searches and a trademark image search of the top concepts.
- Remark
- Not graded: no reverse image or trademark searches were run in this review.
Raw notes
Reverse image searches and a trademark image search of the top concepts.
Not run.
- Run on the next review of this tool once it has a paid plan.
Variety of Concepts
n/aNot Tested- Method
- Count the distinct ideas in the first 20 concepts per brief: a different symbol, layout or type treatment.
- Remark
- Not graded: the scale needs the first 20 concepts per brief, and the free plan paid for four per brief.
Raw notes
Count the distinct ideas in the first 20 concepts per brief: a different symbol, layout or type treatment.
Not counted. The Logo Maker drew four concepts per brief, eight in all, and the free plan did not stretch to 20 per brief.
- Run on the next review of this tool on a plan with credits to spare.
Editing Control
n/aNot Tested- Method
- Ten fixed edits on the coffee roaster logo.
- Edits that worked
- 4 of 10
- Edits not tried
- 5
- Remark
- Not graded: five of the ten edits were not run, so the count says nothing reliable about the other five.
Raw notes
Ten fixed edits on the coffee roaster logo. An edit counts when it did what was asked: by a direct control, or by one prompt that did it.
Worked (4): colour by hex code (a field in the palette editor; the logo and all seven mockups recoloured at once), a one-colour version (one button), icon above the name (the Logo Maker supplies stacked and horizontal versions), and a new typeface on the law logo (one prompt, the symbol stayed).
Did not work (1): add the tagline (the Logo Maker said it cannot).
Not tried (5): letter spacing, swap the icon, edit the icon's shape, resize the icon against the name and undo. The mark changes only by prompt, and the typeface prompt cost 13 credits.
- Run all ten on the next review of this tool on a plan with credits to spare.
Legibility at Small Sizes
4/5Tested- Method
- The two colour logos and their icon-only files were shrunk to 16, 32 and 64 pixels on white with a high quality filter (evaluation/kits/ai-logo-generator/small-sizes.mjs), then looked at true size and enlarged six times without smoothing.
- Name readable from
- 64 px
- Symbol clear at
- 32 px
- Remark
- Scale 4: readable at 64 pixels, symbol clear at 32.
Raw notes
The two colour logos and their icon-only files were shrunk to 16, 32 and 64 pixels on white with a high quality filter (evaluation/kits/ai-logo-generator/small-sizes.mjs), then looked at true size and enlarged six times without smoothing.
Harbour Bean: name readable at 64 pixels, hard to read at 32; the roasting tray symbol is clear at 32 and recognisable at 16.
Calloway and Reed: the clasped hands stay clear at 32 pixels; the thin serif name is soft at 64 and unreadable at 32.
Both packages include an icon-only file, which holds up at 16 pixels.
- Two logos, not three. The 1 cm print in black was not run.
Brand Kit Completeness
3/5Tested- Method
- Both downloaded zips were opened and checked against the ten-point list.
- Items in the law package
- 6 of 10
- Items in the coffee package
- 5 of 10
- Remark
- Scale 3: 6 or 7 of the ten, graded on the fuller of the two packages.
Raw notes
Both downloaded zips were opened and checked against the ten-point list.
Law firm package, six of ten: palette with hex, RGB and CMYK values; horizontal and stacked versions; an icon-only version; one-colour and reversed versions; a business card layout (as a mockup); a brand guide PDF.
Not in the package: named typefaces (the page says "Coming soon"), social profile and cover sizes, a favicon, a letterhead or email signature.
The coffee package held five: the same list without the business card, because that brief's surfaces were social, signage and packaging.
- The brand book PDF is images with no text layer; I read its contents from the Brand Book page.
File Formats
4/5Tested- Method
- Both zips were opened.
- Vector files
- 8 SVG
- PNG size
- 2,048 px, transparent
- Remark
- Scale 4: verified vector, with a JPG, a favicon, a PDF or EPS and a CMYK file missing.
Raw notes
Both zips were opened. The SVG source was read for paths and embedded pictures, and the PNG files were measured with sharp (evaluation/kits/ai-logo-generator/inspect.mjs).
Each package holds eight SVG files (colour, mono, inverse, reversed, horizontal, stacked, icon, wordmark) and the same eight as 2,048 by 2,048 pixel PNG files with a transparent background.
The coffee colour SVG is 49 path shapes with no embedded bitmap and no live text, so it is true vector.
Missing: a JPG, a favicon, a PDF or EPS of the logo (the PDF is the brand book) and a CMYK print file (CMYK values are listed on the page).
- The SVG was read as code, not opened in a vector editor.
Usage Rights & Ownership
1/5Tested- Method
- The terms of service (recraft.ai/legal/terms, read 5 November 2026) and the pricing page FAQ were read for the five rights, as they apply to the free plan I used.
- Rights in writing on free
- 0 of 5
- Remark
- Scale 1: the vendor keeps the rights on the free plan.
Raw notes
The terms of service (recraft.ai/legal/terms, read 5 November 2026) and the pricing page FAQ were read for the five rights, as they apply to the free plan I used.
Ownership: "Free Tier Assets are owned by Recraft and may not be sold, licensed or transferred". Not counted.
Commercial use: "no commercial use of Free Tier Assets is permitted". Not counted.
Not sold to anyone else: not promised; Recraft may show free logos in a public community gallery.
Trademark registration and typeface licences: not addressed. Not counted.
A paid plan changes this: "You own all Assets you create with the Services".
- Terms read by me, not a lawyer. The paid terms were read but not tested on a bought plan.
Ease of Use & Speed
5/5Tested- Method
- Clock and steps from opening the Logo Maker to a zip on disk, for each brief, with the colour edits of the coffee run inside its time.
- Median time to files
- 4 min 44 s
- Steps to a file
- 12 to 14
- Remark
- Scale 5: median under 10 minutes and 15 steps (two of the three briefs; the third was not run).
Raw notes
Clock and steps from opening the Logo Maker to a zip on disk, for each brief, with the colour edits of the coffee run inside its time.
Coffee: 6 minutes 15 seconds and 12 steps. Law firm: 3 minutes 12 seconds and 14 steps. The median of the two is 4 minutes 44 seconds.
Four concepts took about 50 seconds; the first one appeared about 22 seconds after Generate on the coffee run.
The steps: Get Started, name, what it does, Next, feel, Next, the agent's style pick, Generate, Pick, Accept, Export, Download all.
- Times come from scripted runs without think time.
Pricing & Value
4/5Tested- Method
- Every plan was read on the pricing page with both billing views on 5 November 2026.
- Cheapest paid route
- $12 for one month
- Remark
- Under $30 but a subscription, not a one-off price: the nearest rung is 4.
Raw notes
Every plan was read on the pricing page with both billing views on 5 November 2026. I did not buy.
The cheapest route to a logo you may use commercially is Basic at $12 a month ($10 a month yearly).
Pro is $20 a month ($16 yearly) and adds video.
Recraft says images made during a paid plan stay private and yours after you cancel. Not tested.
- No plan bought. I did not check that Basic includes SVG export from the Logo Maker.
Coverage
Tested
- Two logos from two briefs, four concepts each
- Colour by hex code, one-colour version, a typeface request and a tagline request
- Two full downloads, opened and measured
- Small-size renders of both logos and their icon-only versions
- Terms and pricing read in full
Not tested or limited
- The free plan's 148 credits paid for 8 concepts, so the first 20 concepts per brief could not be made
- The coding school brief was not run: another brief would have taken the balance past 85 percent
- Originality searches were not run
- Five of the ten edits were not tried: each asks the AI to redraw the logo and costs credits
- No plan was bought: paid ownership, the paid file set and cancellation were not tested
Still to test
- Design quality, originality, variety and the five untried edits on a paid plan
- Ownership and the paid file set after buying Basic
- The printed 1 cm test
- Cancellation