RankDude

Test log

Playground test data

Raw results for the Playground review. The verdict is in the review.

Tested
5 November 2026
Tester
Miles Foster
Account
Free demo account, signed up by RankDude, nothing paid to the brand
Tests
10
Screenshots
7
Environment
Google Chrome on desktop

Results

IDTestKey measurementScore
T01Design Quality & Brief FitLogos made: 3n/a
T02Originality–n/a
T03Variety of Concepts–n/a
T04Brand Kit Completeness–n/a
T05Legibility at Small SizesName readable from: 64 px4/5
T06Editing ControlEdits that worked: 5 of 102/5
T07File FormatsLargest PNG: 1,024 px2/5
T08Usage Rights & OwnershipRights in writing: 2 of 52/5
T09Ease of Use & SpeedTime to first logo: 15 to 17 s5/5
T10Pricing & ValueCheapest vector route: $15 for one month4/5
Overall (in the review)3.4/5
T01

Design Quality & Brief Fit

n/aNot Tested
Method
Three fixed briefs, one prompt each, typed into the Logo page (briefs in src/data/methodology/briefs/ai-logo-generator.json).
Logos made
3
Spelled right
2 of 3
Remark
Not graded: the scale scores the five best of 20 concepts per brief (15 logos) and uses three outside judges. The free plan gave three logos.

Playground: The three logos side by side.

Playground: The three logos side by side.
T01-1 The three logos side by side.
Raw notes

Three fixed briefs, one prompt each, typed into the Logo page (briefs in src/data/methodology/briefs/ai-logo-generator.json).

Coffee roaster, Auto setting: name and tagline right, no purple or neon green, warm brown and cream; the word Bean is pale cream.

Family law firm, Auto setting: name and tagline right, navy, no red or orange, two joined rings.

Children's coding school, Playground v3: name misspelled, tagline garbled, brown used although the brief said to avoid it.

  • Outside judges were not used. The plan allowed three logos, not twenty per brief.
T02

Originality

n/aNot Tested
Method
Reverse image searches and a trademark image search of the top concepts.
Remark
Not graded: no reverse image or trademark searches were run in this unattended test.
Raw notes

Reverse image searches and a trademark image search of the top concepts.

Not run.

  • Run on the next review of this tool once it has a paid plan.
T03

Variety of Concepts

n/aNot Tested
Method
Count distinct ideas in the first 20 concepts per brief.
Remark
Not graded: twenty concepts per brief were not possible on three included generations.
Raw notes

Count distinct ideas in the first 20 concepts per brief.

Playground returned one logo per prompt.

  • Each extra concept costs one generation.
T04

Brand Kit Completeness

n/aNot Tested
Method
Ten-point checklist of the downloaded package.
Remark
Not graded: the methodology says a free tier often cannot finish this test; a bought logo is needed.
Raw notes

Ten-point checklist of the downloaded package.

The free download is one PNG, with no palette, guide or other files.

  • Retest after buying a plan.
T05

Legibility at Small Sizes

4/5Tested
Method
The two logos I could save were shrunk to 16, 32 and 64 pixels on white with a high quality filter (evaluation/kits/ai-logo-generator/small-sizes.mjs), then looked at true size and enlarged six times without smoothing.
Name readable from
64 px
Symbol clear at
32 px
Remark
Scale 4: readable at 64 pixels, symbol clear at 32.

Playground: Both saved logos at 16, 32 and 64 pixels, true size and enlarged.

Playground: Both saved logos at 16, 32 and 64 pixels, true size and enlarged.
T05-1 Both saved logos at 16, 32 and 64 pixels, true size and enlarged.
Raw notes

The two logos I could save were shrunk to 16, 32 and 64 pixels on white with a high quality filter (evaluation/kits/ai-logo-generator/small-sizes.mjs), then looked at true size and enlarged six times without smoothing.

Law firm: name readable at 64 pixels, fuzzy but readable at 32, rings clear at both; at 16 the rings blur and the name is lost.

Coffee roaster: Harbour reads at 32 pixels; Bean is pale cream and fades; the tagline is unreadable at all three sizes.

No simplified icon was offered.

  • Two logos, not three. The 1 cm print in black was not run.
T06

Editing Control

2/5Tested
Method
Ten fixed edits on the coffee roaster logo.
Edits that worked
5 of 10
Generations used for edits
3 on Playground v3
Remark
Scale 2: 3 to 5 of the ten.

Playground: The colour tool with a hex code: the whole picture became a flat block.

Playground: The colour tool with a hex code: the whole picture became a flat block.
T06-1 The colour tool with a hex code: the whole picture became a flat block.
Raw notes

Ten fixed edits on the coffee roaster logo. An edit counts when it did what was asked: by a direct control, or by one prompt that did it.

Worked (5): typeface (prompt, redrew the whole logo), swap icon to an anchor (prompt, redrew the whole logo), one-colour version (prompt, redrew the layout), add the tagline (text tool), undo to the start.

Did not work (5): set a colour by hex (the colour tool filled the whole picture with a flat block), letter spacing, icon above the name, edit the icon's shape and resize the icon against the name (the logo is one flat picture with no separate parts).

  • Four of the five failures were judged from the controls on screen, not by prompting: that would have spent more generations.
T07

File Formats

2/5Tested
Method
Both saved files were opened with sharp (evaluation/kits/ai-logo-generator/inspect.mjs) to read size and background; the export menu was read for the other formats.
Largest PNG
1,024 px
Vector files
0
Remark
Scale 2: no true vector, largest PNG under 2,000 pixels and not transparent.

Playground: The export menu with SVG locked behind Pro.

Playground: The export menu with SVG locked behind Pro.
T07-1 The export menu with SVG locked behind Pro.
Raw notes

Both saved files were opened with sharp (evaluation/kits/ai-logo-generator/inspect.mjs) to read size and background; the export menu was read for the other formats.

Both PNG files are 1,024 by 1,024 pixels with a solid white background (corner pixel 255, 255, 255, 255).

The menu offers PNG and JPEG. SVG is marked Pro and locked. Upscaling and background removal are Pro.

  • A Pro plan would change this; none was bought.
T08

Usage Rights & Ownership

2/5Tested
Method
The terms of service (playgroundai.com/terms, read 5 November 2026) and the pricing page were read for five rights.
Rights in writing
2 of 5
Remark
Scale 2: commercial use only, plus the statement that you keep what rights you have.

Playground: The licence paragraph of the terms.

Playground: The licence paragraph of the terms.
T08-1 The licence paragraph of the terms.
Raw notes

The terms of service (playgroundai.com/terms, read 5 November 2026) and the pricing page were read for five rights.

Ownership: "you retain any right, title, and interest you may have in and to your Inputs and Outputs" (counted).

Commercial use: the pricing page lists a "World-wide, royalty free license" on every plan (counted).

Not sold to anyone else: not promised; outputs are "not necessarily unique" and assets are public and remixable by default (not counted).

Trademark registration: not addressed (not counted).

Typefaces licensed for logo use: not addressed (not counted).

  • Terms read by me, not a lawyer.
T09

Ease of Use & Speed

5/5Tested
Method
Clock and steps from opening the Logo page to a file on disk, for each brief.
Time to first logo
15 to 17 s
Steps to a file
6
Remark
Scale 5: median under 10 minutes and 15 steps (the third brief counted as unfinished; the median is the middle brief).

Playground: The Logo page with a brief typed in.

Playground: The Logo page with a brief typed in.
T09-1 The Logo page with a brief typed in.
Raw notes

Clock and steps from opening the Logo page to a file on disk, for each brief.

First logo: law firm 15 seconds, coding school 17 seconds; the coffee brief was not timed.

Six steps to a saved file: open the Logo page, click the prompt, type, send, open Export, press Download.

Coffee and law firm saved. The third download hit the daily limit and opened an upgrade prompt.

  • Times come from scripted runs without think time.
T10

Pricing & Value

4/5Tested
Method
Every plan was read on the pricing page and in the upgrade dialog on 5 November 2026.
Cheapest vector route
$15 for one month
Remark
Under $30 but a subscription, not a one-off price: the nearest rung is 4.

Playground: The pricing page with Pro and Pro Plus yearly prices.

Playground: The pricing page with Pro and Pro Plus yearly prices.
T10-1 The pricing page with Pro and Pro Plus yearly prices.
Raw notes

Every plan was read on the pricing page and in the upgrade dialog on 5 November 2026. I did not buy.

The cheapest route to a vector file is Pro at $15 a month ($12 a month yearly).

Pro Plus is $45 a month ($36 yearly).

Not checked: what happens to files after a subscription ends.

  • No plan bought.

Coverage

Tested

  • Three logos from three briefs
  • Ten fixed edits on the coffee logo (five tried directly or by prompt)
  • Saving two files, and a third attempt at the daily limit
  • Small-size renders of the two saved logos
  • Terms and pricing read in full

Not tested or limited

  • The free plan includes three standard generations a month, so the first 20 concepts per brief could not be made
  • Originality searches were not run
  • The third logo could not be saved, so legibility rests on two logos and the 1 cm print step was skipped
  • No plan was bought: vector files, brand kit and cancellation were not tested
  • Brief three used Playground v3 because the main allowance was nearly spent

Still to test

  • Design quality, originality, variety and brand kit on a paid plan
  • Vector files and what happens to them when a subscription ends
  • The printed 1 cm test
  • Cancellation
What these results meanRead the full Playground review