Test log
FreeLogoDesign test data
Raw results for the FreeLogoDesign review. The verdict is in the review.
- Tested
- 5 November 2026
- Tester
- Miles Foster
- Account
- Free demo account, signed up by RankDude, nothing paid to the brand
- Tests
- 10
- Screenshots
- 8
- Method
- Published methodology
- Environment
- Google Chrome on desktop
Results
| ID | Test | Key measurement | Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| T01 | Design Quality & Brief Fit | AI tokens on free: 0 | n/a |
| T02 | Originality | – | n/a |
| T03 | Variety of Concepts | – | n/a |
| T04 | Brand Kit Completeness | – | n/a |
| T05 | Legibility at Small Sizes | Name readable from: 64 px | 4/5 |
| T06 | Editing Control | Edits that worked: 9 of 10 | 4/5 |
| T07 | File Formats | Largest free file: 200 px | 2/5 |
| T08 | Usage Rights & Ownership | Rights in writing: 1 of 5 | 2/5 |
| T09 | Ease of Use & Speed | Median time: 25 s | 5/5 |
| T10 | Pricing & Value | Cheapest vector route: $44.99 once | 4/5 |
| Overall (in the review) | 3.7/5 | ||
Design Quality & Brief Fit
n/aNot Tested- Method
- The three fixed briefs were to be typed into the AI tool.
- AI tokens on free
- 0
- Templates per search
- 24
- Remark
- Not graded: the scale scores the five best of 20 AI concepts per brief on an eight-point checklist. These are shared templates, not concepts drawn for my brief.
Raw notes
The three fixed briefs were to be typed into the AI tool. With 0 tokens that was not possible, so I searched the template gallery with each brief's company name and picked the nearest template.
AI tool: I typed the coffee brief and pressed Generate. A box offered token packs (10 for $4.99, 35 for $15.99, 90 for $34.99) and made nothing.
Templates: the gallery fills your company name into 24 logos per search. Coffee: a cup logo with Harbour Bean spelled right. Law: a template with Calloway & Reed spelled right. Coding: a template with Pixel Pioneers spelled right.
Some templates keep another name: Mercer & Emerson, Smith & Reeves and Jones & Kidman in the law search, PATHOS in the coffee search, and HARBOU cut short on a banner.
- Outside judges were not used and no AI concept was made.
Originality
n/aNot Tested- Method
- Reverse image searches and a trademark image search of the top concepts.
- Remark
- Not graded: a template shown to every user cannot be tested for originality the way a drawn concept can.
Raw notes
Reverse image searches and a trademark image search of the top concepts.
Not run: the logos are templates that every user sees.
- Run on a paid review with AI concepts.
Variety of Concepts
n/aNot Tested- Method
- Count distinct ideas in the first 20 concepts per brief.
- Remark
- Not graded: no AI concepts could be made.
Raw notes
Count distinct ideas in the first 20 concepts per brief.
Not run: the AI tool needs tokens. The template search returns 24 logos, which are ready-made, not concepts for the brief.
- Each AI concept costs tokens.
Brand Kit Completeness
n/aNot Tested- Method
- Ten-point checklist of the downloaded package.
- Remark
- Not graded: my own logo has no kit on the free plan, and a sample of another logo is not my package.
Raw notes
Ten-point checklist of the downloaded package.
The free download is one 200 pixel PNG, with no palette, guide or other files. The Premium sample package (the vendor's own sample logo) holds black and white versions, social media sizes, a favicon, business cards, invoices and a brand guide.
- Retest after buying Premium.
Legibility at Small Sizes
4/5Tested- Method
- The three downloaded logos were shrunk to 16, 32 and 64 pixels on white with a high quality filter (evaluation/kits/ai-logo-generator/small-sizes.mjs), then looked at true size and enlarged six times without smoothing.
- Name readable from
- 64 px
- Symbol clear at 32 px
- 2 of 3
- Remark
- Scale 4: readable at 64 pixels, symbol clear at 32 on two of the three; the law mark is the exception.
Raw notes
The three downloaded logos were shrunk to 16, 32 and 64 pixels on white with a high quality filter (evaluation/kits/ai-logo-generator/small-sizes.mjs), then looked at true size and enlarged six times without smoothing.
Coffee roaster: Harbour Bean reads at 64 pixels; at 32 the cup is clear and the name is not; the tagline is unreadable at every size.
Law firm: Calloway & Reed reads at 64 pixels; at 32 the name is a grey line and the mark is not clear; the tagline is unreadable.
Coding school: Pixel Pioneers reads at 64 pixels and just about at 32; the screen mark is clear at 32 and still a block of colour at 16.
No simplified icon was offered.
- The free files are only 200 pixels wide, so these renders start from a small picture. The 1 cm print in black was not run.
Editing Control
4/5Tested- Method
- Ten fixed edits on the coffee roaster logo.
- Edits that worked
- 9 of 10
- Generations used
- 0
- Remark
- Scale 4: 8 or 9 of the ten.
Raw notes
Ten fixed edits on the coffee roaster logo. An edit counts when it did what was asked, with a direct control and no workaround.
Worked (9): typeface (Tilt Warp to Special Elite), colour by hex (#8B4513 on the name), icon above the name (dragged, stayed), letter spacing (0 to 4), swap the icon (deleted the cup, added a coffee bean from the icon search), add the tagline (Roasted slow, poured fresh, set on a curve), resize the icon against the name, a one-colour version (every palette colour set to #000000) and undo back to the start (13 clicks).
Did not work (1): edit the icon's shape. A selected icon offers a fill and an outline colour, nothing to reshape.
Resizing the icon scaled its lines separately from the name, so the layout broke and needed fixing by hand.
- The right-hand panel is cut off at a 1,366 pixel window, so I showed the page at 80% to reach it. The editor shows an advert strip on the free plan.
File Formats
2/5Tested- Method
- The three free downloads were opened with sharp (evaluation/kits/ai-logo-generator/inspect.mjs): pixel size, format and the colour of the corner.
- Largest free file
- 200 px
- Vector files on free
- 0
- Remark
- Scale 2: no true vector on the plan I used, the PNG is under 2,000 pixels and not transparent.
Raw notes
The three free downloads were opened with sharp (evaluation/kits/ai-logo-generator/inspect.mjs): pixel size, format and the colour of the corner. The package page and the vendor's Basic sample package were read for what a paid plan adds.
All three free PNG files are 200 by 200 pixels with a solid background (cream for the coffee logo, white for the other two). The page calls the file Low-Res PNG (200x200 px).
The Basic sample package holds an SVG made of real paths, a 5,000 pixel PNG and a JPG; it uses the vendor's sample logo, not mine. Vector files, a transparent background and high resolution are marked as paid.
- Paid files were not made from my logo. A paid plan would change this grade.
Usage Rights & Ownership
2/5Tested- Method
- The terms of use (freelogodesign.org/terms-of-use, read 5 November 2026) and the package page were read for the five rights.
- Rights in writing
- 1 of 5
- Remark
- Scale 2: commercial use only.
Raw notes
The terms of use (freelogodesign.org/terms-of-use, read 5 November 2026) and the package page were read for the five rights.
Commercial use: "You may use the logos created for personal or commercial purposes."
Ownership: not transferred in the terms. They say "Logos not selected and not paid by the customer remain the property of Freelogodesign." The Privilege card says "Complete ownership of your logos", which is the sales page, not the terms.
Not sold to anyone else: not promised. The terms say the company cannot guarantee a logo "will not be identical, or similar to logos" made by other users.
Trademark registration: not granted; the Exclusive Logo "does not include copyright and trademark licenses".
Typefaces licensed for logo use: not stated.
- Terms read by me, not a lawyer. The terms are under Quebec law.
Ease of Use & Speed
5/5Tested- Method
- Each brief was timed with a clock and a step counter on the template route, from opening the app to the free PNG on disk (evaluation/kits/ai-logo-generator/ease.mjs).
- Median time
- 25 s
- Median steps
- 11
- Remark
- Scale 5: median under 10 minutes and 15 steps.
Raw notes
Each brief was timed with a clock and a step counter on the template route, from opening the app to the free PNG on disk (evaluation/kits/ai-logo-generator/ease.mjs). Each click, typed entry and page opening is a step.
Coffee roaster: 25 seconds, 11 steps. Law firm: 25 seconds, 11 steps. Coding school: 24 seconds, 11 steps.
The templates showed after about 8 seconds. The steps: open the app, type the company name, Begin, type a keyword, search, pick a template, open the layers, select the tagline, type it, Download, Free download.
On the law firm's first run no file was saved (39 seconds); I ran it again and counted the second run.
- Timed runs with no pauses for choosing, on an account that was already signed in; a logo that needs choosing takes longer by hand.
Pricing & Value
4/5Tested- Method
- Every package was read on the public offers page and on the package page inside the editor on 5 November 2026.
- Cheapest vector route
- $44.99 once
- Remark
- $30 to $59, one-off: 4.
Raw notes
Every package was read on the public offers page and on the package page inside the editor on 5 November 2026. I did not buy.
The cheapest route to a vector file with commercial use is Basic at $44.99 once, with the old price of $65.00 crossed out.
Premium is $59.99 and Unlimited $89.99, both once. The Privilege Pack is $64.99 a year; the terms say the discount applies to the first year only.
All sales are final under the refund terms. Logos can be downloaded again by logging in.
- No plan bought, so the Basic file set was not checked on my own logo.
Coverage
Tested
- Template search and a template for each of three briefs
- Nine of ten fixed edits on the coffee logo; the tenth, reshaping the icon, has no control
- Three free downloads, opened and measured
- Small-size renders of all three logos
- Terms, pricing page, package page and the vendor's free sample packages read
Not tested or limited
- The account had 0 AI tokens, so the AI generator could not be run on any brief
- Originality searches were not run; the logos are shared templates
- No plan was bought: vector files, brand kit and cancellation were not tested on my own logo. The free sample packages on the pricing page use the vendor's own sample logo
- The 1 cm print step was not run
- Times come from timed runs with no pauses for choosing, on an account that was already signed in
Still to test
- The AI generator, design quality, originality and variety with tokens
- Basic or Premium files made from my own logo, and the brand kit
- The printed 1 cm test
- Cancellation of the Privilege Pack